The verdict
A mixed-report mid-size suv, strong on space and held back by efficiency.
The 2019 Buick Enclave is a big, quiet, comfortable three-row crossover that hauls people and gear better than most of the mid-size class — 97.6 cu ft of maximum cargo room, 23.6 cu ft still left behind an occupied third row, and a cabin one reviewer called 'quieter than a library'. What you give up is efficiency and equipment: 21 MPG combined from the only engine offered (a 310-hp 3.6L V6), roughly $2,950 a year in fuel, and a driver-assistance list where automatic emergency braking, lane keep assist and adaptive cruise are all extra-cost items the volume Essence trim can't even order. As a used buy it is compelling precisely because it depreciated hard — about 41% of its $45,195 sticker survives at five years — so today's shopper gets the space and the silence for a fraction of the original ask. Go in knowing the nine-speed automatic has a documented shudder pattern and that a 2019 needs its build date checked for the passenger-side crash reinforcement.
Jump to scoresStrengths
- Cargo room that beats the class
- A genuinely quiet, well-damped cruiser
- Five-star crash results
What holds it back
- Depreciation is among the worst in the class
- Thirsty, with no hybrid to fix it
- The safety tech is optional, and often unavailable
Top alternatives
Cars shoppers cross-shop with the Buick Enclave
2.79B-
Kia TellurideMid-Size SUVBetter at: Resale valueSimilar three-row space and content for thousands less, with a 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain warranty and far stronger five-year resale.
Compare
2.88B-
Toyota Grand HighlanderMid-Size SUVBetter at: EfficiencyHybrid powertrains cut the Enclave's roughly $2,200/yr fuel bill sharply, and Toyota's proven mechanicals remove the new-engine risk.
Compare
2.72B-
Chevrolet TraverseMid-Size SUVBetter at: PriceThe identical platform, 2.5-liter turbo and 328 hp for thousands less, if you can live without the Buick cabin materials and QuietTuning.
CompareHow it's evolved
10 scored model years · 2017–2026
Subject scores by year
Hover or tap a score to see what moved it versus the year before. A corner mark flags a big swing.
| Year | Performance | Efficiency | Safety | Space | Cost | Reliability | Tech | Use-case | Driving | Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 52 | 56 | 71 | 78 | 38 | 69 | 83 | 64 | 65 | 71 |
| 2025 | 51 | 48 | 85 | 81 | 34 | 65 | 84 | 62 | 62 | 69 |
| 2024 | 50 | 38 | 57 | 75 | 36 | 72 | 60 | 61 | 63 | 58 |
| 2023 | 48 | 37 | 60 | 75 | 38 | 76 | 65 | 61 | 61 | 66 |
| 2022 | 47 | 37 | 61 | 76 | 41 | 76 | 65 | 62 | 61 | 66 |
| 2021 | 45 | 38 | 57 | 74 | 40 | 71 | 52 | 58 | 60 | 63 |
| 2020 | 46 | 38 | 57 | 73 | 43 | 69 | 50 | 59 | 63 | 62 |
| 2019 | 46 | 38 | 55 | 73 | 46 | 69 | 48 | 58 | 63 | 67 |
| 2018 | 47 | 38 | 55 | 73 | 52 | 60 | 48 | 57 | 65 | 65 |
| 2017 | 40 | 24 | 45 | 73 | 51 | 61 | 34 | 55 | 56 | 57 |
Compare two years
Best fit & conditions
Higher scores mean a better fit for that use case. Learn more about use-case fit →
Subject profile
Detailed scoring by subject
1Performance & PowertrainOne of the Enclave's weakest categories.1.07D
2019 is the second year of the second-generation Enclave (2018–2024) and a mechanical carry-over: the sole naturally aspirated 3.6L V6 is unchanged, with the year's revisions confined to trim naming and equipment. Strong output for the class, but delivered by a large-displacement V6 rather than anything electrified.
Peak torque of the sole 3.6L V6, unchanged for 2019 — adequate but modest for a 4,350–4,700 lb three-row, and the peak arrives high enough that the nine-speed has to downshift to make progress under load.
Genuinely quick for a mainstream-premium three-row — the naturally aspirated V6 gives the Enclave a real step on the turbo-four competition — but no outlet instrumented a 2019 specifically, so the figure is taken from the identical 2018/2020 cars and adjusted down slightly for the lighter FWD volume trim.
No turbo to lag and no hybrid handoff to smooth, so delivery is linear and the V6 stays quiet at a cruise — reviewers consistently describe it as tuned for effortlessness rather than urgency, which suits the Enclave's mission, but it turns audibly coarse when wrung out toward its 6,800 rpm power peak and the auto stop/start is the least polished part of the experience.
The GM nine-speed automatic shifts smoothly and stays out of the way in ordinary driving, but with peak torque high in the rev range it drops multiple gears for passing and can hunt on grades; reviewers also flag the shifter itself as a usability irritant rather than the gearbox's calibration.
Properly equipped, the Enclave matches the strongest ratings in the unibody three-row class at 5,000 lbs — but only with the optional Trailering Package, and Cars.com lists the un-equipped car at just 1,500 lbs with either a dead-weight or weight-distributing hitch.
AWD is a roughly $2,000 option rather than standard equipment and cannot be ordered at all on the base Preferred, but 2019 falls inside the good window for the hardware: AWD Premium and Avenir models carry GM's twin-clutch rear differential, which shuffles torque side to side for traction and cornering, and which GM dropped from the Enclave after 2020. There is still no low range and no terrain-mode suite.
A pavement-first luxury crossover — about 8 in of ground clearance, no skid plates, no lockers, no terrain or off-road drive modes and no off-road trim anywhere in the 2019 range; the twin-clutch rear diff on AWD Premium and Avenir helps on a snowy driveway or a gravel road, and that is the extent of it.
One engine, one transmission, take it or leave it — the 3.6L V6 and nine-speed automatic are the entire 2019 offering, with no turbo four, no hybrid and no plug-in anywhere in the range; the only drivetrain decision a buyer makes is FWD versus AWD.
2Efficiency & RangeThe Enclave's lowest-graded category.0.48F
A 4,350+ lb three-row on a naturally aspirated V6 with nothing electrified in the range beyond stop/start — 21 MPG combined is mid-pack among large gas crossovers of 2019 and well behind the turbo-four and hybrid rivals in the class.
City economy is the Enclave's weakest figure — mass plus a naturally aspirated V6 with no hybrid assist and no engine-off capability beyond auto stop/start.
The nine-speed's tall top gears and the second generation's lower, more aerodynamic body make the highway number the Enclave's best result — respectable for a large three-row, though still short of the class's hybrid options.
Roughly 400 miles between fills for the volume FWD configuration — fine for family road-trip duty — and AWD models actually travel farther because GM fits them a notably larger tank.
One of the higher running costs in the mid-size SUV set, a direct consequence of the 21 MPG combined figure; the saving grace is that it burns regular rather than premium.
The 3.6L V6 runs on regular 87-octane unleaded across every 2019 trim including Avenir — no premium surcharge, which meaningfully narrows the real per-mile gap to premium-fuel rivals despite the mediocre MPG.
3SafetyGrades below the middle of the scale.1.67D
NHTSA rated both the 2019 Enclave FWD and AWD 5 stars overall, with 5 stars side including the pole test, 4 stars frontal (5 driver / 4 passenger) and 4 stars rollover with no tip in the dynamic test.
The 2019 Enclave is Good in every original IIHS crashworthiness test — both small overlap fronts, moderate overlap, original side, roof strength and head restraints — but the passenger-side Good is build-date conditional and covers only 2019 cars built after December 2018, so early-build 2019s fall outside it. It earned no award (IIHS never published a headlight rating for the 2019 model year, and an award requires one), and the later updated side test returned only Acceptable with a Marginal structure score.
The volume Essence gets Lane Change Alert with Side Blind Zone Alert, Rear Cross Traffic Alert and rear park assist as standard, and nothing else — no automatic emergency braking, no forward collision alert, no lane keep assist and no adaptive cruise are even orderable on that trim. The collision-avoidance half of the suite is confined to the Driver Confidence Package II on Premium and Avenir, and unlike 2020 that package is still an extra-cost box rather than standard equipment, so a 2019 Enclave with AEB is the exception rather than the rule.
Where fitted the system tests very well — IIHS rated front crash prevention Superior vehicle-to-vehicle and Superior for daytime pedestrian detection, with the Avenir Technology Package's enhanced system rated Advanced — but it is optional equipment on the top two trims and cannot be had at all on the Preferred and the volume Essence, and there is no nighttime pedestrian evaluation for this generation.
Lane Change Alert with Side Blind Zone Alert and Rear Cross Traffic Alert are standard from Essence up, which covers most of the volume, and rear park assist comes with them — but the coverage is warning-only, with no rear cross-traffic braking, no active blind-spot steering intervention and no safe-exit alert, and the base Preferred cannot get any of it.
Lane Keep Assist with Lane Departure Warning is confined to the extra-cost Driver Confidence Package II on Premium and Avenir, so the base Preferred and the volume Essence have no lane assistance available at any price — and no 2019 trim offers lane centering at all, the system being a nudge-off-the-line assist rather than a centering aid.
Adaptive cruise is a top-trim-only extra — it exists solely inside the Avenir Technology Package, so three of the four trims including the volume Essence are stuck with fixed-speed cruise. The full-speed-range system is competent when equipped, but nothing is layered on top of it as a highway assist.
No hands-free highway system is offered at any price — for 2019 GM's Super Cruise was still a Cadillac CT6-only feature and was never fitted to the second-generation Enclave.
IIHS published no headlight rating for the 2019 Enclave, but the identical LED bi-functional projector headlamps carried into 2020-21 were rated Marginal in both tested variations, with low beams leaving the left side of a straightaway and the sharp left curve inadequately lit. The 2019 car is worse off than the 2020 on the one variable that changed: IntelliBeam auto high beams are not available on Preferred or Essence at all and are an extra-cost item even on Premium and Avenir, and no variation is curve-adaptive.
The Enclave's tall, upright greenhouse and deep side glass give better-than-average forward and quarter sightlines for a three-row crossover, and camera compensation is genuinely available — the rear camera mirror and Surround Vision are on the 2019 order sheet for the upper trims. On the volume Essence, though, that compensation is limited to the standard rear vision camera and rear park assist: thick D-pillars and third-row headrests pinch the over-the-shoulder view, front park assist is Premium/Avenir-only, and the surround-view system is out of reach.
IIHS did not publish a child-seat anchor rating for the 2019 model year, but the second-generation interior is unchanged and the rating IIHS later assigned to the same hardware is Acceptable: two second-row positions carry complete LATCH hardware and three more have tether anchors only, with lower anchors buried too deep in an outboard position. Wide rear doors, second-row captain's chairs with a fore/aft slide for third-row access and a genuinely usable third row make it practical for families, but the deep anchors mean real digging and third-row seats can only be tethered.
4Space & ComfortThe Enclave's best-graded category.2.97B-
2019 is the second year of the second-generation Enclave and a carry-over for interior packaging: seven seats in a 2-2-3 layout on Preferred, Essence, Premium and Avenir, with second-row captain's chairs the only configuration offered — there is no eight-seat bench option.
GM publishes one first-row headroom figure for the 2019 Enclave with no separate with/without-moonroof number, and it is unchanged from the 2018 launch car.
Front legroom is the weakest of the Enclave's interior dimensions — the 120.9-inch wheelbase is spent on the second and third rows rather than the front, leaving the driver mid-pack for the class.
Second-row headroom sits near the top of the SUV band — the second-generation Enclave is dimensionally a full-size crossover competing in the mid-size class, and even the third row's 37.6 in beats many rivals' second rows.
38.9 inches in the second row is generous for the class, and the Smart Slide captain's chairs slide fore and aft so the family can trade that space with the third row rather than being fixed at one setting.
33.5 in of third-row legroom and 37.6 in of headroom genuinely seat adults when the Smart Slide second row is set mid-travel, and reviewers of the 2019 car call that a class rarity; access is one-sided — the tilt-and-slide function is passenger-side only — and the cushion is short on thigh support, which keeps it a kids-and-short-trips seat against a Volkswagen Atlas.
58.0 cu ft with the second row up and the third row folded is the figure this item asks for; the more telling number is the 23.6 cu ft that survives behind an occupied third row, which reviewers of the 2019 car called best-in-class.
Near the top of the SUV band and a genuine Enclave strength — with everything folded it out-hauls most mid-size three-rows and matches vehicles a size class above.
A lockable 10-inch-deep under-floor bin behind the third row is a real above-segment touch, joined by a deep centre console, six USB ports spread two-per-row and a 120-volt outlet inside the navigation option packages; there is no headline innovation on the order of a giga-console or onboard generator.
Heated power front seats are standard right down to the base Preferred and Premium/Avenir add ventilated fronts and heated second-row captain's chairs, with reviewers calling the first two rows firm, supportive and spacious; the massaging front seats that lift the 2020 car do not exist yet for 2019, the third-row cushion is thin, and some owners report fatigue on long stints.
Ride is the Enclave's signature: the five-link rear suspension delivers a firm-but-compliant, well-damped ride that reviewers praise on the standard chassis, with Continuously Variable Real-Time Damping available in the Avenir premium suspension package, and little of the wallow big soft crossovers usually trade for it.
QuietTuning with Active Noise Cancellation is standard fleet-wide and backed by hardware — triple door seals, acoustic laminated glass and the noise-reducing five-link rear axle — and reviewers of the 2019 car single the Enclave out for isolation even against premium-badged rivals.
Tri-zone automatic climate control, heated power front seats and fob remote start are standard on every trim including the base Preferred, with an automatic heated steering wheel and heated second-row captain's chairs standard on Premium and Avenir; app-based preconditioning needs a paid Remote Access plan and there is no massage function for 2019.
5Cost of OwnershipOne of the Enclave's weakest categories.1.09D
2019 added a new front-wheel-drive Preferred trim as the entry point at $40,000 before destination, lowering the Enclave's price of entry versus 2018 when Essence was the base trim. Premium mid-size three-row positioning still sits well above mainstream rivals.
Essence is the volume trim — it adds leather, 20-inch wheels and the driver-assist content most buyers want, and AWD is a common add in this segment. Prices drifted slightly upward during the model year, with some sources quoting Essence at $44,690 delivered.
Model-specific estimates for the Enclave cluster around $600–$720 per year, and the naturally-aspirated 3.6L V6 with the 9-speed automatic is a proven, widely-shared GM powertrain rather than a new design. Adjusted upward from those figures for premium-brand dealer labor rates and the post-warranty fifth year.
The Enclave is one of the weaker residual performers in the three-row class — heavy incentive spending (rebates of 14% or more were common in 2019) and rental/fleet exposure both push used values down, and it retains well below the Buick brand average.
Buick's 4-year/50,000-mile new-vehicle limited warranty runs a year longer than most mainstream brands and matches near-luxury rivals like Acura, but falls short of Hyundai/Kia's 5-year coverage.
Buick's 6-year/70,000-mile powertrain coverage was, as Car and Driver noted at launch, the longest among the Enclave's direct near-luxury rivals — but it remains well short of the 10-year/100,000-mile coverage Hyundai and Kia offer in the broader three-row market, which is where this band's ceiling sits.
The 2019 model year is exactly when GM cut Buick's complimentary maintenance from three years to a single visit — one oil change, tire rotation and multi-point inspection redeemable within the first 12 months. Six years of roadside assistance and courtesy transportation tied to the powertrain term plus short OnStar/4G LTE trials round it out, which is thin next to multi-year programs from Toyota, BMW or Genesis.
$45,195 volume-trim price minus its estimated resale value after 5 years (41% retained, or about $18,530) leaves about $26,665 in depreciation. Add the projected $4,500 in 5-year maintenance and repairs, and owning this vehicle for 5 years costs about $31,165 in total.
6Reliability & QualityOne of the Enclave's strongest categories.2.68C+
2019 is the second year of the second generation (2018-2021 pre-refresh, the refresh having slipped to 2022), so nothing about the car changed — but the forecasts split, and the more consumer-facing of the two is negative. Consumer Reports rates the 2019 Enclave less reliable than other vehicles of its model year, listing minor transmission trouble (gear selector, transmission sensors), in-warranty exhaust pipe leaks, alternator failures and complete A/C failures among its trouble spots; that is a step down from CR's read on the 2020 and 2022-2023 cars, which it recommends. J.D. Power is warmer at 75/100 for quality & reliability, inside its 70-80 'Average' band. The field record sits between the two: 42 NHTSA complaints for MY2019 against 56 for MY2020 and 25 for MY2021. Scored below the 2020 sibling because CR's verdict flips against this year specifically.
Buick was a genuine top-five dependability brand across the whole window a 2019 buyer would have been reading, and it stayed there afterwards. J.D. Power's 2019 U.S. Vehicle Dependability Study placed Buick 5th at 118 PP100 against a 136 industry average, behind only Lexus (106), Porsche and Toyota (108 each) and Chevrolet (115); the brand then improved to 3rd at 103 PP100 in the 2020 VDS and 2nd in 2022, so this is a sustained multi-year standing rather than one good year. Held a few points under the 2020 model-year card because the Consumer Reports half of the picture had not yet arrived — CR's brand ranking put Buick 3rd in its November 2020 report, the first American brand in its top three in 35 years, which is after this model year rather than behind it.
One recall, and it is a fleet-wide GM supplier campaign rather than anything specific to this car: 20V668000 covers a start/stop transmission accumulator endcap with missing bolts that can leak fluid to a loss of propulsion or, with an ignition source, a fire. That is severe in kind but narrow in cause, and it sweeps in the Cruze, Equinox, Traverse, Terrain, Malibu and Encore alongside the Enclave. The contrast with the adjacent model year is the whole story here — the 2020 car carries six recalls including a cracked engine-compartment frame rail, a roof-rail airbag inflator and two overcured-tire campaigns, none of which touch the 2019. What keeps this out of the top band is the bulletin record: the front exhaust pipe's mounting bracket separates often enough that GM issued Special Coverage N212356540 for 2019 Enclave and Traverse, and MY2019 NHTSA filings describe both front exhaust welds broken with a rattle. That the coverage runs 15 years / 150,000 miles is a genuine mitigation the 2020 car does not get.
The engine is the solid half: the naturally aspirated 3.6L LFY V6 (310 hp / 266 lb-ft) is a mature GM high-feature V6 with long fleet service and no systemic failure mode, and 2019 changes nothing about it. The nine-speed 9T65 behind it is what drags the score. Its documented mode is torque-converter clutch slip — shudder at a steady 30-60 mph cruise and harsh engagement — and MY2019 NHTSA filings read exactly that way: shuddering and hard shifting at 30-40 mph, a GM-prescribed fluid flush followed by transmission failure at 72,000 miles, a torque converter condemned by the dealer while still in warranty. The start/stop accumulator recall is a transmission-fluid-leak item on top of that, and the C1XX front exhaust pipe weld failure recurs across the year's complaints. Nothing here is a catastrophic design fault and GM covers the exhaust repair to 15 years, which keeps this in the middle band rather than below it, but a nine-speed with a named shudder pattern is well short of the proven-powertrain tier.
2019 sits three model years ahead of the refresh that addressed exactly this complaint — the redressed dash, added soft-touch surfaces and standard leather-appointed first and second rows all arrive with the 2022 car. What is here is a split cabin: reviewers find soft-touch and leather above the beltline and genuinely rich materials in the Avenir (chestnut leather, wood accents), but U.S. News is direct that the interior materials are not as nice as some classmates', and the wood on the top trim is simulated. This item is price-relative and the registry places the Enclave in the Premium class against the Volvo XC90, Acura MDX and Lincoln three-rows Buick chose to target, so a cabin that is pleasant at mid-trim and merely competitive at the top belongs just under the middle of the band. Matched to the 2020 sibling, which is the same unrefreshed interior.
Brand initial quality was fine but not the standout it became: Buick posted 92 PP100 in the J.D. Power 2019 Initial Quality Study against a 93 industry average — one point better than average, a far thinner margin than the 150 vs 166 the brand managed in 2020. The vehicle-specific record is what holds this in the middle. The front exhaust pipe's mounting bracket separates from the pipe often enough on the 2019 Enclave and Traverse that GM opened a 15-year / 150,000-mile special coverage for it, and MY2019 owners report both front welds broken with a persistent rattle — a weld defect is as plain an assembly problem as there is. Against that, Lansing Delta Township was in its second year on this body and the 2019 avoids the cracked frame-rail recall that hit the 2020, so this is scattered defects rather than anything systemically loose.
Service is the strongest thing about owning this car. Buick ranked highest of all mass-market brands in the J.D. Power 2019 Customer Service Index at 857 — its third consecutive win — ahead of MINI (853), Mitsubishi (846), Chevrolet (845), GMC and Toyota (840 each), so dealer service satisfaction was class-leading in this model year rather than merely adequate. Coverage was at full strength too: the US network still ran to roughly 2,000 franchises (1,958 entering 2023, before GM's EV-transition buyout roughly halved it) and most stores are dual Buick-GMC points, putting a GM service bay within reach almost anywhere in the country. Kept just below the top of the band because the CSI measures the service visit specifically, and Buick's showing in Consumer Reports' broader owner-satisfaction survey over the same period is markedly cooler.
Availability is not the issue — the Enclave shares its C1XX platform, 3.6L LFY V6 and 9T65 nine-speed with the high-volume Chevrolet Traverse and GMC Acadia, so component commonality is high, GM's distribution is broad and independent shops stock what the car needs. Cost is: RepairPal puts the Enclave's average annual repair and maintenance spend at $720 against a $608 Buick brand average, and while shop visits are infrequent at 0.3 per year, a 13% chance of any given repair being severe on a three-row crossover with a nine-speed automatic is the real exposure. Scored a few points above the 2020 car for one reason specific to this model year: the front exhaust pipe repair that a 2020 owner pays for out of pocket (about $1,000 in owner filings) is covered on a 2019 to 15 years / 150,000 miles under N212356540.
7Technology & InfotainmentGrades below the middle of the scale.1.24D
Buick fitted one 8-inch diagonal display across the entire 2019 Enclave range, and the packages that add navigation run on the same panel; small even by 2019 standards and unchanged from the 2018 launch car.
The IntelliLink-derived Buick Infotainment System of 2019 is responsive and one of the more logically laid out systems of its era, with physical volume/tuning knobs and hard climate controls retained beneath the screen; it is the generation before the next-generation system and connected navigation that arrive for 2020, and the small 8-inch panel and dated graphics show it.
Apple CarPlay and Android Auto are standard on all four 2019 trims — better than several rivals of the year, which still charged for them — but both are wired-only, and no 2019 trim or package offers wireless projection.
Built-in navigation is standard only on Avenir and otherwise an extra-cost package on Essence and Premium, so the volume Essence typically ships without it; the embedded voice recognition is command-list based rather than natural language, and most owners default to CarPlay or Google Maps.
The Bose performance-enhanced 10-speaker system with amplifier and subwoofer is standard on Premium and Avenir and optional on Essence, and it is a genuinely good system for the class; the standard six-speaker setup on Preferred and base Essence is unremarkable.
Every 2019 Enclave uses analog gauges flanking a colour Driver Information Center; only Avenir gets the larger 8-inch reconfigurable enhanced DIC, and even that is a big centre screen between physical dials rather than a full-digital cluster.
The 2019 Enclave predates GM's Vehicle Intelligence Platform electrical architecture, so there are no whole-vehicle over-the-air updates; OnStar delivers connected services and app content, but map data and module software are a dealer or USB job — even the connected navigation that would refresh maps over the air is a 2020 addition.
The myBuick app covers the core set — remote start/stop, lock/unlock, fuel level, vehicle location and service scheduling — and fob remote start is standard on every trim, but the app-based remote functions sit behind a paid Remote Access plan after the trial and there is no phone-as-key.
Six USB ports spread two-per-row is genuinely good third-row provision for 2019 and the OnStar Wi-Fi hotspot is standard fleet-wide, but the ports are USB-A rather than USB-C, wireless charging is Avenir-standard or an upper-trim option, and the 120-volt household outlet only arrives inside the navigation packages — so the volume Essence often has neither.
Keyless entry and push-button ignition, fob remote start and a hands-free power liftgate are all standard on every trim including the base Preferred — unusually generous for 2019 — with LED logo projection to aim the kick sensor; the gaps are phone-as-key, which does not exist, and app remote start, which needs a subscription.
A rear vision camera and rear park assist are standard fleet-wide, and Surround Vision plus a rear camera mirror are on the 2019 order sheet, but both are Avenir Package content and front park assist is buried in the extra-cost Driver Confidence Package II — so the volume Essence has a rear camera and rear sensors and nothing more, and no trim offers automated parking.
No head-up display was offered on the 2019 Enclave at any trim or in any package — it appears in neither the Avenir standard-equipment list nor the available driver-assistance roster, and the feature never reached the second-generation car.
8Use-Case FitMid-pack among this car's ten categories.1.89C-
The Smart Slide passenger-side second-row seat slides and pitches for third-row access even with an empty forward-facing child seat still latched in place — a genuine class differentiator — paired with a standard hands-free power liftgate, 58.0 cu ft behind the second row for strollers and IIHS-Acceptable LATCH hardware; the caveat is that the tilt-and-slide function is passenger-side only.
Crash results are strong — NHTSA 5-star overall and IIHS Good in every original crashworthiness test — and a rear-seat reminder and Teen Driver are standard, but 2019 is the weakest year of the generation for driver assistance: forward collision alert, automatic emergency braking and lane keep assist are extra-cost package content even on Premium, unavailable at any price on the volume Essence's price point without stepping up, and adaptive cruise is Avenir-package-only.
Tri-zone climate and six USB ports reach all three rows, the cabin is exceptionally quiet, and a best-in-class 23.6 cu ft survives behind an occupied third row — enough luggage for seven, which is the hard part of a seven-seat road trip; heated second-row chairs are a Premium-and-up item and no rear-seat entertainment system was offered on any 2019 trim.
A 310-hp V6 with a smooth-shifting nine-speed, light steering effort, a compliant ride and a very quiet cabin make it a low-fatigue commuter; the recurring irritants are the awkward electronic gear selector reviewers single out and the sheer 204-inch length in tight daily traffic.
21 MPG combined front-drive and 20 MPG with AWD from a naturally aspirated V6 is mediocre even by 2019 three-row standards, with EPA annual fuel costs around $2,950–$3,100; the mitigations are regular-grade fuel and ordinary consumables rather than anything structural.
A 39.0 ft curb-to-curb circle is tidy for the size and rear camera plus rear park assist are standard on every trim, but 204.3 in long by 89.3 in across the mirrors is a full-size footprint in a mid-size class, and the tools that make it easy in a garage — front park assist and Surround Vision — are extra-cost package content or Avenir-only.
5,000 lbs of towing with the optional Trailering Package is respectable for a unibody crossover and Hitch Guidance with Hitch View helps hook up, but the package cannot be ordered on the FWD-only Preferred, an unequipped Enclave is rated for just 1,500 lbs, and there is no bed, no meaningful payload rating and no work-oriented drivetrain.
The 3.6L LGX V6 and nine-speed are long-serving GM hardware shared with the Traverse and Acadia, but the Enclave is a leather-and-wood-trimmed family crossover with cloth only on the base trim, no fleet or commercial reputation, and a 4-year/50,000-mile basic warranty that does not reflect any work-duty intent.
Provisions amount to cargo tie-downs, a lockable 10-inch-deep under-floor bin, an optional trailer hitch and a 120-volt outlet bundled inside the navigation packages; there are no washable surfaces, no onboard work power of any consequence and no upfitter ecosystem — GM explicitly disclaims warranty coverage on alterations.
Quiet, well-damped and roomy with roughly 400–430 miles between fills, the Enclave is a natural highway cruiser; what holds it back is driver assistance — adaptive cruise exists only inside the Avenir Technology Package, so every other trim including the volume Essence has plain fixed-speed cruise and no lane centering, and some owners report seat fatigue on long stints.
Twin-clutch intelligent AWD with Traction Select, 5,000 lbs of tow rating and roof rails handle gravel roads, trailheads and bike or kayak duty, but 7.7 in of ground clearance, road-biased all-season tires, no skid plates, no off-road drive mode and no AWD at all on the base Preferred keep it firmly on the light-duty end.
97.6 cu ft with both rear rows folded flat is near the top of the segment and 23.6 cu ft behind an occupied third row was called best-in-class in 2019, backed by power-folding third-row seats on the upper trims, a lockable 10-inch-deep under-floor bin, roof rails and an available hitch — bulky gear is a strength rather than a squeeze.
9Driving ExperienceMid-pack among this car's ten categories.2.27C
The five-link rear suspension gives the Enclave more body control than its soft-riding character suggests and reviewers call it respectably agile for a 4,350-lb three-row that corners without drama, but it is tuned for serenity rather than pace and lacks the high-speed solidity of the European rivals the second generation was aimed at.
The electric variable-assist rack is accurate and reasonably weighted on centre with an active return-assist function, and no 2019 reviewer criticizes its precision, but assist is deliberately tuned light so a 204-inch crossover parks easily and it transmits very little of the road surface.
Four-wheel ventilated discs with ABS on a 4,358-lb-and-up crossover deliver adequate, predictable stops with a firm-enough pedal and no reported fade complaints, but no published instrumented stopping distance was located for the 2019 car and nothing about the brakes stands out in reviews either way.
The naturally aspirated 3.6L V6 pulls cleanly with no turbo lag and the nine-speed automatic shifts unobtrusively in normal driving, but the standard stop/start system restarts with a noticeable shudder, the transmission drops multiple gears for a quick pass because peak torque sits at 2,800 rpm, and the electronic gear selector itself draws consistent criticism.
Active noise cancellation and laminated acoustic glass are fitted across the range and keep the V6 well in the background at cruise; it only becomes audible approaching its 6,800-rpm power peak, where the note is smooth rather than coarse.
39.0 ft is respectable for a 204.3-inch car on a 120.9-inch wheelbase, but it is mid-pack against the compact-and-mid-size SUV band this item normalizes over, and it is the number that makes the Enclave feel large in a parking structure.
A commanding seating position, power driver's seat and tilt/telescoping column standard from the base trim, a high centre console that makes a huge vehicle feel snug, and a dashboard that keeps physical climate and audio controls beneath the 8-inch screen make it easy to settle into; memory presets are an upper-trim item and the electronic shifter is the one control everyone stumbles over.
The Enclave is deliberately engineered for calm — quiet, soft-edged and unflustered — and offers no steering feedback, exhaust character or throttle sharpness an enthusiast would seek out; there is no sport trim, no sport suspension outside the Avenir comfort-oriented package, and reviewers describe the acceleration as effortless precisely because it does nothing for the pulse.
10Value & Market PositionOne of the Enclave's strongest categories.2.50C+
The new-for-2019 Preferred trim brings the price of entry down but is plainly equipped for a $41K premium three-row — cloth seating, a modest 8-inch touchscreen, and driver-assist content (blind-spot, forward automatic braking, adaptive cruise) still relegated to higher trims or option packages. Volume Essence trim fills the gaps with leather, 20-inch wheels and second-row captain's chairs, but rivals bundle more at the same money.
The Enclave delivers real substance for the money — 310 hp, three genuinely usable rows, class-leading cargo room and a quiet cabin — but it asks a meaningful premium over its mechanically-related Chevrolet Traverse, and a loaded Avenir at $57K collides with established luxury badges. Fair value at Essence, thin value at the top of the range.
Four well-spaced trims — Preferred, Essence, Premium and Avenir — spanning roughly $41K to $57K, each available with front- or all-wheel drive, plus a choice of seven- or eight-passenger seating. Only one powertrain is offered, which caps configuration flexibility.
2019 was the best sales year the nameplate ever posted — 51,156 US deliveries, up from 49,648 in 2018 and 48,564 in 2017 — with Q1 2019 running 27% ahead of Q1 2018. A rising, healthy mid-pack seller, though far behind the Explorer/Highlander/Pilot volume tier.
Buick in 2019 sat in a neutral-to-mildly-positive space: strong dependability standing and a genuinely upscale product, but an older buyer demographic and none of the aspirational pull of Acura, Lexus or the German marques it was newly positioned against. The Enclave's move upmarket for the second generation outran the badge.
Discounting on the 2019 Enclave was unusually generous and widely available, which is a substantial real-world buyer benefit even though it signals soft demand and feeds the model's weak residuals. Very few premium three-rows transacted this far under sticker.
2019 is year two of the second generation launched for 2018 on GM's long-wheelbase C1XX architecture with the 310-hp 3.6L V6 and nine-speed automatic — still a current, recently-redesigned platform, with 2019 adding the Preferred trim and a standard heated steering wheel on Premium and Avenir. No redesign risk on the horizon.
Reviewers consistently praised the ride quality, cabin space and quietness, and singled out the class-best powertrain warranty, but faulted interior materials at the price and driving engagement — the Enclave was a recommended alternative rather than the pick of the class. Solid rankings and finalist nods, but no marquee award.
