The verdict
A mixed-report compact suv, strong on safety and held back by ownership.
Overall 2.20 (C) across 10 graded subjects. Its strongest is safety at 3.28 (B+), its weakest cost of ownership at 0.62 (F). 6 of 10 subjects grade at C− or better.
Jump to scoresStrengths
- Safety
- Technology & Infotainment
- Value & Market Position
What holds it back
- Cost of Ownership
- Space & Comfort
- Reliability & Quality
Top alternatives
Cars shoppers cross-shop with the Ford Mustang Mach-E
2.60C+
Tesla Model YCompact SUVBetter at: Road tripsMore range, much faster charging and native Supercharger access make it the better long-distance EV for similar money.
Compare
2.74B-
Hyundai Ioniq 5Compact SUVBetter at: Charging speed800-volt charging does 10–80% in under 20 minutes versus the Mach-E's 36, with a roomier cabin and longer warranty.
Compare
2.06C
Chevrolet Equinox EVCompact SUVBetter at: ValueMore range and more space for less money, if you want an affordable electric crossover rather than a quick one.
CompareHow it's evolved
6 scored model years · 2021–2026
Subject scores by year
Hover or tap a score to see what moved it versus the year before. A corner mark flags a big swing.
| Year | Performance | Efficiency | Safety | Space | Cost | Reliability | Tech | Use-case | Driving | Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 59 | 62 | 86 | 44 | 48 | 66 | 77 | 61 | 77 | 64 |
| 2025 | 57 | 62 | 87 | 47 | 46 | 64 | 78 | 61 | 76 | 69 |
| 2024 | 56 | 62 | 84 | 44 | 42 | 65 | 77 | 63 | 76 | 67 |
| 2023 | 52 | 57 | 83 | 44 | 39 | 49 | 77 | 61 | 75 | 65 |
| 2022 | 53 | 57 | 83 | 44 | 43 | 43 | 80 | 60 | 75 | 73 |
| 2021 | 53 | 57 | 78 | 45 | 40 | 45 | 78 | 58 | 75 | 78 |
Compare two years
Best fit & conditions
Higher scores mean a better fit for that use case. Learn more about use-case fit →
Subject profile
Trims & configurations
4 trimsScores above reflect the volume trim. Per-trim specs and scores are rolling out — the full lineup:
Detailed scoring by subject
1Performance & PowertrainGrades below the middle of the scale.1.55D
Premium eAWD Extended Range is the volume trim for launch-year MY2021, making 346 hp; base RWD Standard/Extended Range trims make 266–290 hp and the mid-year GT tops the range at 480 hp.
Premium eAWD Extended Range makes 428 lb-ft; Select RWD makes 317 lb-ft, Select eAWD 428 lb-ft, GT reaches 600 lb-ft (634 lb-ft on the GT Performance Edition).
Ford's own estimate for the Premium eAWD Extended Range volume trim is 4.8 s. California Route 1 (RWD, Extended Range) is slowest at 6.1 s due to its heavier pack, Select RWD is 5.8 s, GT is 3.8 s, and the GT Performance Edition is quickest at 3.5 s.
Single- and dual-motor EV drivetrains deliver immediate, linear power with no lag or hesitation; reviewers consistently praised the launch-year Mach-E's smooth, quiet power delivery.
Single-speed direct-drive EV transmission with no shifting, hunting, or drone — seamless by nature of the powertrain. The launch-year Mach-E uses the console-mounted rotary gear-selector dial (the column-stalk shifter didn't arrive until the 2025 refresh), which some reviewers found less intuitive than a traditional lever.
Ford does not publish a US tow rating for any 2021 Mach-E trim, and the owner's manual explicitly states it is not approved for towing trailers in the US. European-market Extended Range/eAWD models carry a separate braked tow rating of roughly 2,204 lbs (1,000 kg) that does not apply in the US market this site covers.
eAWD (dual-motor) is available as an option on Select and Premium and standard on GT; California Route 1 is RWD-only in its 2021 launch configuration. Widely available across the lineup but not standard on every trim.
The 2021 Mach-E lineup (Select, Premium, California Route 1, GT) is purely pavement-oriented: 5.8-inch ground clearance, street tires, and no skid plating or terrain modes. The off-road-flavored Rally trim with its lift and underbody protection wasn't introduced until MY2025.
The Mach-E is battery-electric only — no gas, hybrid, or PHEV option — so despite multiple battery sizes and motor configurations, it's a single powertrain type, take-it-or-leave-it for buyers who don't want an EV.
2Efficiency & RangeMid-pack among this car's ten categories.1.81C-
Re-scored on the AWD Extended Range battery rather than the Standard Range pack: Ford reported over 80% of US Mach-E reservations took the extended-range battery and ~55% took AWD, making AWD/ER the volume configuration for the launch year (and matching how the 2022 scorecard is configured). 90 MPGe trails the RWD variants but still far exceeds any gas compact SUV.
Regenerative braking makes stop-and-go the Mach-E's strongest cycle; 96 MPGe city is well clear of any gas SUV in the segment. Changed from the prior run only because the volume configuration was corrected to AWD Extended Range.
Highway MPGe falls off from the city figure as is typical for EVs (little regen at speed, higher aero load), but 84 MPGe still comfortably beats gas SUV highway ratings. Changed only because the volume configuration was corrected to AWD Extended Range.
Large upward correction: the prior run scored the AWD Standard Range pack (211 mi), which was not the volume configuration and produced a spurious 211→277 mi jump between the 2021 and 2022 scorecards. The 98.8 kWh AWD Extended Range pack most 2021 buyers ordered is EPA-rated 270 mi — competitive for a 2021 compact EV SUV, though short of the RWD California Route 1's 305-mi lineup max and of any gas SUV's tank range.
New item this run. 150 kW was competitive against the 2021 field's e-tron and I-Pace but well behind the 800V Hyundai/Kia E-GMP cars that arrived the same year, and Ford's own real-world curve tapers early.
New item this run. Ford's own quoted 45 minutes for the Extended Range pack sits at the bottom of the segment band — the larger 98.8 kWh battery takes longer than the Standard Range pack despite the same 150 kW ceiling, and the taper means the average rate over the session is far below peak.
Now taken directly from the EPA listing rather than derived by hand, and for the corrected AWD Extended Range configuration: $850/yr at the agency's standard 15,000 mi/yr electricity assumptions — well under any gas SUV, though above the $750/yr the RWD configs post.
240V Level 2 home charging is standard, practical and cheap for daily use, with no fuel-grade requirement at all. Trimmed from the prior run's 90 to align with the 2022 scorecard: 2021 predates Ford's May 2023 NACS announcement, so public fast charging was confined to CCS networks (Electrify America via the FordPass Charging Network) with no Tesla Supercharger access.
3SafetyThe Mustang Mach-E's best-graded category.3.28B+
NHTSA's full test battery on the 2021 Mach-E returned a 5-star overall rating, with 5 stars in both side-impact and rollover testing.
The 2021 Mach-E earned Good ratings in all six IIHS crashworthiness tests (small overlap front driver and passenger, moderate overlap front, side, roof strength, head restraints) plus a Superior front crash prevention rating, netting a Top Safety Pick award. It missed the higher TSP+ tier only because the base Select/California Route 1 trims' LED reflector headlights rated Marginal (Premium/GT/First Edition's LED projector headlights rated Good).
Ford Co-Pilot360 Assist 2.0 — AEB, adaptive cruise control, blind-spot monitoring, rear cross-traffic alert, lane-keeping assist, and automatic high beams — is standard equipment across every 2021 Mach-E trim including base Select, a comprehensive suite with no trim gating.
IIHS rated the Mach-E's front crash prevention Superior for both vehicle-to-vehicle and vehicle-to-pedestrian scenarios, the top tier available in 2021-era testing.
Blind-spot monitoring and rear cross-traffic alert are standard on every trim as part of Co-Pilot360 Assist 2.0, but coverage is alert-based rather than active-intervention.
Base lane-keeping assist (warning + nudge) is standard on all trims, but true lane-centering is bundled into the optional Co-Pilot360 Active 2.0 package on the base Select trim (standard on Premium/California Route 1/GT/First Edition), so volume-trim buyers get the more basic keep-assist experience.
Adaptive cruise control is standard across the range, but the integrated highway-assist experience (lane centering paired with ACC) requires the optional Active 2.0 package on the base Select trim, so the base-trim highway-assist experience is less refined than on equipped trims.
BlueCruise arrived on the Mach-E via an over-the-air update in late 2021, standard on California Route 1, Premium, and First Edition trims equipped with Active 2.0 and available as an add-on for Select, but it was a first-year rollout with a smaller mapped 'Blue Zone' highway network than later model years.
The base Select and California Route 1 trims' standard LED reflector headlights rated Marginal by IIHS, while the Premium/GT/First Edition's LED projector headlights rated Good — since Select is the volume trim, most buyers get the weaker-rated lighting.
Reviewers found sightlines good over the driver's left shoulder but only fair to the right, with the sloped fastback-style roofline mildly compromising rear visibility despite not costing headroom.
IIHS rated LATCH ease of use Acceptable, better than many compact SUVs — anchors sit behind marked upholstery slits and are easy to locate, and generous rear legroom (~38 in) comfortably accommodates rear-facing infant seats and multi-seat setups.
4Space & ComfortOne of the Mustang Mach-E's weakest categories.0.99F
The Mach-E launched for 2021 as a strict two-row, 5-passenger compact SUV across Select/Premium/California Route 1/First Edition/GT; no third-row or 6/7-seat configuration was ever offered.
Manufacturer-published front headroom figure for the launch-year Mach-E, consistent across trims.
Edmunds specs list 41.5 in front legroom for the 2021 model year; some aggregator listings show a slightly higher figure, so a small measurement discrepancy is possible.
Manufacturer-published second-row headroom for the 2021 Mach-E, roomy for a compact SUV given the fastback roofline.
Manufacturer-published second-row legroom, above segment mid-pack given the Mach-E's long wheelbase and flat EV platform floor.
No third row is offered in any 2021 Mach-E configuration — it's a fixed 5-seat, two-row layout, so this scores at the bottom of the band by definition.
Manufacturer-published cargo volume behind the second row; toward the low end for the compact-SUV segment band.
Manufacturer-published max cargo with second row folded, excluding the frunk; near the bottom of the SUV max-cargo band.
A standard, sizable 4.7 cu ft front trunk (with drain plug for use as a cooler) plus a deep center-console bin and large door pockets were standout features at launch, before Ford later shrank and gated the frunk on subsequent model years.
Edmunds and other launch reviews praised front and rear cushioning as soft yet supportive ('memory foam that breathes'), though they noted a lack of thigh-extension adjustment and limited lateral bolstering.
Reviewers found the standard suspension absorbs bumps and potholes well without harshness, but some criticized shock-valving choices that keep the ride from being fully smooth over rougher pavement.
Launch reviews described the cabin as 'absolutely silent' with no engine noise and little wind or road noise intrusion, a strong result for the segment at the time, though a few reviewers flagged some highway wind noise.
Heated front seats and a heated steering wheel are standard from Premium up but only available on Select via the optional Comfort/Technology Package; no rear climate or remote pre-conditioning beyond FordPass app scheduling.
5Cost of OwnershipThe Mustang Mach-E's lowest-graded category.0.62F
The 2021 launch-year Mach-E opened at $42,895 for the Select RWD Standard Range trim, a mid-pack entry price for the compact SUV band.
Premium was the volume configuration most 2021 buyers chose over base Select, adding a panoramic sunroof, hands-free liftgate, and heated seats.
As an EV the Mach-E skips oil changes and transmission service, but Edmunds' model-specific true-cost-to-own tool for the 2021 model year projects a higher combined 5-year maintenance and repair total than segment EV averages, landing it mid-pack rather than best-in-class.
The Mach-E is among the steepest-depreciating vehicles on the market, and a 2021 example is now exactly five years old, retaining barely a third of its original value as EV resale values have been hit hard by newer competitors and price cuts.
Ford's standard New Vehicle Limited Warranty of 3 years/36,000 miles applies unchanged to the 2021 model year and sits at the bottom of the mainstream-brand band.
Ford backs the 2021 Mach-E's battery and drive unit for 8 years/100,000 miles with a guaranteed minimum 70% capacity retention, longer than the conventional 5-year/60,000-mile powertrain norm applied to non-EV driveline parts.
No complimentary scheduled maintenance is included, but launch-year buyers received a 250 kWh Electrify America fast-charging credit, 22,000 FordPass Rewards points, and two years of complimentary FordPass Charging Network access with the subscription fee waived, plus standard roadside assistance for the warranty term - a modest but slightly richer one-time perk package than later model years.
$47,600 volume-trim price minus its estimated resale value after 5 years (39% retained, or about $18,564) leaves about $29,036 in depreciation. Add the projected $6,051 in 5-year maintenance and repairs, and owning this vehicle for 5 years costs about $35,087 in total.
6Reliability & QualityOne of the Mustang Mach-E's weakest categories.1.02D
Consumer Reports' retrospective data rates the 2021 Mach-E as less reliable than other vehicles from its model year, and it has since accumulated roughly 13 NHTSA recall campaigns — a launch-year EV with real teething problems rather than the above-average debut some early press coverage suggested.
Ford ranked 18th of 28 brands in Consumer Reports' 2021 reliability survey — an improvement from 22nd the prior year but still below the industry average — and Ford dealers scored below the industry average (833 vs. 843) in J.D. Power's 2021 Customer Service Index.
The 2021 Mach-E carries a heavy, safety-critical recall load directly tied to its launch-year hardware: overheating high-voltage battery main contactors (loss of drive power, crash risk) on extended-range/GT models, an OTA-related ABS brake-assist loss recall, the later 197,432-unit door-latch recall (occupant entrapment risk) spanning 2021-2025 MY, plus windshield-bonding and panoramic-glass-panel separation recalls and a liftgate water-leak TSB — a pattern of repeated, often safety-relevant campaigns rather than isolated minor issues.
As Ford's first-generation dedicated EV powertrain, the 2021 Mach-E's high-voltage battery/drive unit had a known, real-world failure mode — main contactors overheating under DC fast-charging and hard acceleration, capable of stranding the vehicle — that led to a class-action suit and recall; Ford has since mitigated it with hardware/software fixes, but the 2021 build predates those fixes.
Reviewers found the cabin's minimalist, Scandinavian-inspired design and ActiveX synthetic-leather seating punch above its price point, though multiple outlets flagged harder, 'flimsy' plastics in secondary touch zones and noted the ActiveX material feels squishier than real leather — solidly competitive but short of class-leading.
Some launch reviewers praised tight, rattle-free assembly, but a persistent pattern of owner-reported liftgate and door-panel rattles, a factory water-leak TSB for the liftgate taillight seals, and safety recalls covering windshield bonding and panoramic-glass-panel separation point to real first-year build-quality gaps.
Ford's ~3,000-dealer US network gave the Mach-E broad physical coverage from day one, but 2021 was also the network's first year servicing a dedicated high-voltage EV platform, and J.D. Power's 2021 Customer Service Index ranked Ford dealers 14th among mass-market brands and below the industry average.
Routine upkeep is cheap and simple (no oil changes; RepairPal/CarEdge estimate ~$185 average annual service, roughly $1,613 over 10 years/150,000 miles), but as a first-model-year EV the Mach-E's high-voltage components — including the recalled battery contactors — required dealer-sourced parts and specialist repair with a less-mature supply chain than later model years.
7Technology & InfotainmentOne of the Mustang Mach-E's strongest categories.3.27B+
The Mach-E launched in 2021 with its signature 15.5-inch portrait touchscreen standard on every trim from Select through GT, at the very top of the compact SUV normalization band.
SYNC 4A debuted on the Mach-E to strong reviews for its smartphone-like responsiveness and card-based UI on the huge portrait display, though it was a first-generation system with occasional early software rough edges.
Wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto were standard across all 2021 Mach-E trims at launch, notably ahead of most rivals still requiring a cable at the time.
SYNC 4A included cloud-connected native navigation and a voice assistant at launch, functional but not yet natural-language conversational, so many owners preferred phone projection.
The base Select trim shipped with a 6-speaker system, while Premium, First Edition, and GT trims got a 10-speaker, 560-watt Bang & Olufsen system with a subwoofer — solid but not the largest system in the segment.
A 10.2-inch digital instrument cluster was standard across all 2021 trims, clean and legible though modest in size relative to some larger configurable clusters in the segment.
Ford's over-the-air update program (later branded Power-Up) launched with the Mach-E in December 2020, delivering whole-vehicle UI and module/firmware updates as a headline feature, comparable to EV-native rivals.
The FordPass app offered remote start, lock/unlock, window control, liftgate, panic alarm, and a proximity-based Welcome Mode that auto-adjusted seats/mirrors/radio, plus EV charge status — a rich free feature set at launch, though it lacked a true phone-as-key entry system.
A wireless charging pad was included from launch along with USB connectivity, a notable convenience feature for a 2021-model-year vehicle, though full USB-C proliferation to rear-seat passengers was not confirmed.
The 2021 Mach-E came standard with a SecuriCode B-pillar keypad, push-button start, and FordPass remote start/lock plus proximity Welcome Mode — a comprehensive keyless suite even without a phone-as-key digital key system.
A 360-degree camera with split-view display was available on the 2021 Mach-E alongside standard rear camera and parking sensors, ahead of many segment rivals at the time.
Ford did not offer a head-up display on the 2021 Mach-E on any trim, opting instead for the 10.2-inch digital instrument cluster as its substitute.
8Use-Case FitMid-pack among this car's ten categories.1.87C-
A full 4.7 cu ft frunk is standard on every 2021 trim (no paywall as in later model years), giving families extra stroller/gear space, though rear door openings on the fastback profile are a bit tighter than a boxier crossover for wrangling car seats.
NHTSA awarded a 5-star overall rating and IIHS named the 2021 Mach-E a Top Safety Pick (missing the higher Plus tier only because not every trim's headlights rated Good/Acceptable); Ford Co-Pilot360 2.0 — including automatic emergency braking, blind-spot monitoring, and lane-keep assist — is standard on every trim from the base Select up.
29.7 cu ft behind the rear seats is modest for the class, but the standard 4.7 cu ft frunk adds meaningful extra luggage room for a family trip that later model years lost to a paid option; rear seat comfort on multi-hour drives is adequate but unremarkable.
Smooth single- and dual-motor EV power delivery with selectable One-Pedal Drive make stop-and-go traffic relaxed, and the Mach-E was the first Ford offered with Active Drive Assist hands-free highway driving — a first-generation system, less polished than later BlueCruise revisions but a genuine daily-driving asset.
The volume Premium AWD Extended Range trim rates roughly 88-90 MPGe combined (270-mile EPA range) — well below any gas SUV's per-mile cost, though behind the most efficient RWD-only configurations and behind later model-year Mach-E efficiency gains.
Compact-SUV footprint and a standard rear-view camera make city parking manageable, though a 360-degree camera system was not standard on the base Select trim in 2021, and the fastback's thick rear roofline limits over-shoulder visibility.
Ford offered no towing package at all for the 2021 Mach-E — not even the aftermarket hitch hardware that later became available — and cargo capacity (59.7 cu ft max) is unremarkable, making it the least work-capable model year of the nameplate.
As an all-new first-model-year EV platform, the 2021 Mach-E was hit with a major NHTSA recall (48,294 vehicles, expanded further in 2023) for high-voltage battery main contactors overheating and welding shut or opening under DC fast charging and hard acceleration, causing loss of drive power — a serious durability red flag unresolved by a single fix and requiring follow-up recalls.
No onboard power-export feature and no marketed tie-down/upfit ecosystem, but the standard (non-paywalled) 4.7 cu ft frunk is a genuine, unusually roomy piece of lockable, weatherproof storage for tools or gear that later model years shrank behind a paid option.
Up to 300 miles EPA range on the RWD Extended Range configuration (270 miles on the more common AWD Extended Range) plus first-generation Active Drive Assist hands-free highway driving make it a solid long-distance companion, though early owner and press reports flagged firmer seat bolstering and some highway wind noise typical of the fastback shape.
Ground clearance of roughly 5.1-5.8 inches is on the low side for light off-pavement use, there is no low-range or dedicated off-road mode, and no roof rails are offered given the fastback styling; available AWD helps in snow and on gravel but this is a pavement-focused crossover.
29.7 cu ft behind the rear seats and 59.7 cu ft with them folded sit toward the bottom of the compact-SUV cargo band, but the standard 4.7 cu ft frunk — not yet cut down or paywalled as in later years — meaningfully helps with bulky or dirty gear; no roof rails are offered from the factory.
9Driving ExperienceGrades above the middle of the scale.3.08B
In its launch year the Mach-E impressed reviewers with a flat, composed cornering stance and strong grip for a crossover, aided by the low center of gravity from the underfloor battery pack; the standard/Premium AWD trim stays planted through fast corners even if it stops short of the range-topping GT added the following model year.
The steering is accurately weighted and quicker-geared than a typical crossover, giving confident placement and a 'sports-car responsive' feel that reviewers singled out as a highlight versus segment rivals, though it is still low-geared by modern sports-sedan standards and doesn't transmit much genuine road texture.
Car and Driver's instrumented test of an extended-range AWD Mach-E recorded a 70-0 mph stop of 165 ft, solidly competitive for a compact electric SUV of this era, and the one-pedal regenerative system blends into the friction brakes without abrupt transitions for everyday driving.
As Ford's first dedicated EV, the debut Mach-E's single- and dual-motor drive units deliver instant, linear torque with no shift shock, turbo lag, or stop-start behavior to manage, and reviewers praised the calibration as smooth and confidence-inspiring right out of the gate.
As a battery-electric SUV the 2021 Mach-E is near-silent under normal driving, with only mild motor whine audible under hard acceleration; no dedicated interior dB measurement for the 2021 launch model year was located.
Ford's 2021 Mustang Mach-E spec sheet lists a curb-to-curb turning diameter of 38.1 ft across trims, mid-pack for the compact SUV segment.
The driving position offers a commanding crossover view with straightforward pedal alignment and powered seat adjustment on Premium and above; the fastback roofline's steeply raked rear window creates notable rear blind spots that launch-year reviewers flagged repeatedly.
The debut Premium AWD Extended Range trim is genuinely engaging on a twisty road thanks to instant torque and a tidy, well-controlled chassis that launch reviewers likened to a rear-drive sport sedan more than a typical crossover, though the sharpest enthusiast thrills would arrive with the GT variant the following model year.
10Value & Market PositionOne of the Mustang Mach-E's strongest categories.3.27B+
Every 2021 Mach-E, even the base $42,895 Select, came standard with a 15.5-in portrait touchscreen (largest in the segment at launch), SYNC 4A with cloud-connected navigation, and Ford Co-Pilot360 driver-assist (adaptive cruise, lane-keeping, auto high-beams) — strong standard content versus contemporary compact SUVs and rival EVs.
Pricing ran $42,895-$60,500 (Select to GT) for 211-305 miles of range depending on trim, and unlike Tesla or GM's EVs the Mach-E still qualified for the full $7,500 federal tax credit in 2021, meaningfully improving effective value; the GT's 480 hp/634 lb-ft for roughly $60K was also strong performance-per-dollar.
Launch-year lineup spanned Select, Premium, California Route 1, and GT, each offered with RWD or AWD and Standard or Extended Range battery packs, plus a limited-production First Edition — a genuinely wide, well-spaced range from value-focused RWD Select to performance-focused GT.
In its first full sales year the Mach-E moved 27,140 units in the US, making it the nation's second-best-selling all-electric SUV behind only the Tesla Model Y — a strong debut against a still-thin field of EV crossover rivals.
Borrowing the Mustang name for an SUV was controversial among purists, but it generated enormous buzz and drew cross-shoppers who wouldn't otherwise consider a Ford EV, riding the pony-car halo onto Ford's mainstream trusted-brand base — net a strong desirability boost for a launch-year model.
Ford proactively cut Select/Premium/California Route 1 pricing by $1,000-$3,000 ahead of deliveries, a real buyer-facing win, but once the model launched, strong initial demand plus pandemic-era chip-shortage supply constraints left little room for dealer discounting beyond the base MSRP cut and the federal tax credit.
2021 is the Mach-E's debut model year on an all-new dedicated EV platform — as fresh and cutting-edge as the nameplate ever gets, with no prior generation to be aging against.
The 2021 Mach-E swept a remarkable set of first-year honors — 2021 North American Utility of the Year, Car and Driver's inaugural EV of the Year, Cars.com Eco-Friendly Car of the Year, AutoGuide Utility of the Year, and Autoweek's Car Buyer's Award — an exceptional debut critical reception matched by few launch-year vehicles.
