The verdict
A struggling full-size truck, strong on reliability and held back by efficiency.
The 2023 Nissan Titan is the full-size pickup that stopped competing on capability and started competing on peace of mind: a 400-hp V8 standard on every trim, the highest predicted reliability score of any 2023 pickup, and a 5-year/100,000-mile bumper-to-bumper warranty no domestic rival comes close to matching. What it can't do is work like a modern half-ton — 9,323 lbs of towing and 1,697 lbs of payload are the lowest in the class, closer to a mid-size truck than to an F-150's 13,500 lbs, and 18 MPG combined on recommended premium gas costs about $4,200 a year to feed. Nissan confirmed during this model year that the Titan dies after 2024, which explains both the aggressive discounts a 2023 buyer could get and the ~51% five-year resale that hands much of the savings back. Buy it as a cheap, durable, low-mileage V8 truck you plan to keep; skip it if you tow near the limit or trade every three years.
Jump to scoresStrengths
- The best warranty in the segment, by years and by miles
- Top-rated reliability and cheap running costs
- A 400-hp V8 standard on every single trim
What holds it back
- The lowest tow rating and payload of any full-size truck
- Thirsty, and it wants premium fuel
- Depreciation eats the discount
Top alternatives
Cars shoppers cross-shop with the Nissan Titan
2.20C
Toyota TundraFull-Size TruckBetter at: Resale valueSame import-truck logic with far better economics — 12,000 lbs of towing, a hybrid option, regular fuel, and resale in the mid-60% range against the Titan's 51%.
Compare
2.66C+
Ford F-150Full-Size TruckBetter at: CapabilityThe default cross-shop: 13,500 lbs of towing, five powertrains, three bed lengths, a much roomier back seat, and hands-free highway driving for similar money.
Compare
1.74C-
Nissan FrontierMid-Size TruckBetter at: Running costsIf the Titan's 9,290-lb tow rating is more than you need, the Frontier does most of the same jobs for less money, better fuel economy and easier parking at the same dealer.
CompareSubject scores by year
Hover or tap a score to see what moved it versus the year before. A corner mark flags a big swing.
| Year | Performance | Efficiency | Safety | Space | Cost | Reliability | Tech | Use-case | Driving | Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | 45 | 26 | 54 | 58 | 53 | 67 | 49 | 60 | 61 | 45 |
| 2023 | 45 | 30 | 54 | 58 | 54 | 70 | 49 | 60 | 61 | 50 |
Compare two years
Best fit & conditions
Higher scores mean a better fit for that use case. Learn more about use-case fit →
Subject profile
Detailed scoring by subject
1Performance & PowertrainOne of the Titan's weakest categories.0.99F
Every 2023 Titan — S through Platinum Reserve, King Cab, Crew Cab and XD alike — runs the same naturally aspirated 5.6L Endurance V8, so the volume Crew Cab SV and the flagship share one figure with no trim range to note. Nissan marketed it as the most standard horsepower in the full-size class, and against a base F-150's 325 hp V6 that holds up; but the truck band stretches to 800 hp to accommodate electric pickups, so it normalizes in the lower-middle.
413 lb-ft is respectable for a naturally aspirated V8 but it peaks at 4,000 rpm, well up the rev range, and it is short of the turbocharged and diesel half-tons the Titan competes with — Ford's 3.5L EcoBoost makes 500 lb-ft, Ram's 3.0L EcoDiesel 480 lb-ft. Against a truck band reaching 800 lb-ft it lands low, and the shortfall is the direct reason the Titan's tow ratings trail the class.
Edmunds' instrumented test of the 2023 Titan returned 7.5 seconds and called it unremarkable for a light-duty pickup with a V8 — a fair summary. Same-generation MotorTrend runs bracket it (7.3 s PRO-4X Crew Cab 4x4, 7.4 s XD SL, and 6.3 s for the much lighter SV King Cab 4x2, which the displayValue notes). Against a band anchored by 2.5-second electric pickups, and with turbo and hybrid rivals now in the 5-second range, this scores low. Nissan publishes no factory figure.
The Endurance V8 is the best part of the truck. Being naturally aspirated there is no turbo lag and no hybrid handoff to manage, so throttle response is linear and immediate with a genuinely good V8 note under load, and reviewers consistently describe power delivery as smooth. It gives ground to the forced-induction competition in low-end shove — peak torque at 4,000 rpm means it wants revs to do its best work — and it gets audibly busy when pushed, a fair trade for the complete absence of drivability quirks.
The 9-speed Jatco automatic that arrived with the 2020 refresh has a wide 5.425:1-to-0.597:1 spread and a short 3.692:1 final drive, so it keeps the V8 in its powerband well under load and pulls revs down on the highway. Edmunds specifically praised its smoothness on the 2023 truck. It stops short of the top band because it is not the class benchmark for decisiveness — owner and press reports of the generation note occasional low-speed hesitancy and some indecision among the closely spaced upper ratios, and there are no paddle shifters on the volume trims.
This is the Titan's defining competitive weakness. Nissan's own headline figure of 9,323 lbs made it the lowest-rated full-size half-ton on sale in 2023 — an F-150 tows 14,000 lbs, a Silverado 13,300 lbs, a Tundra 12,000 lbs — and it is only a couple of thousand pounds clear of a well-equipped mid-size Ranger or Colorado. The volume Crew Cab SV 4x4 configuration actually rates 9,136 lbs, below the headline. The heavier-framed Titan XD stretches to 11,033 lbs with the integrated gooseneck hitch, but even that trails the half-ton leaders.
A 1,697 lb ceiling is mid-size territory, not full-size — the Frontier and Tacoma rate about the same, while half-ton rivals routinely clear 2,000 lbs and the payload leaders exceed 2,400. The volume Crew Cab configurations come in lower at 1,558–1,658 lbs and the well-equipped trims lower still (Platinum Reserve 4x2 is only 1,356 lbs), so a real-world Titan buyer sees meaningfully less than the headline. Against a truck band reaching 3,400 lbs this is a genuine capability shortfall rather than a normalization artifact.
The core towing kit is complete and the hardware is good: an integrated trailer brake controller, Tow/Haul mode with downhill speed control, standard Trailer Sway Control, a built-in 4- and 7-pin connector, extendable split towing mirrors, and a remote trailer light check operable from the Intelligent Key — a genuinely useful touch rivals mostly lack. The XD adds a frame-integrated gooseneck hitch with an in-bed plug. What is missing is the advanced layer the Detroit trucks made commonplace by 2023: no trailer backup steering assist, no stored trailer profiles, no onboard scales, no auxiliary trailer camera inputs. The Intelligent Around View Monitor helps line up a hitch but is optional rather than standard, and the trailer brake controller itself is an option on S and SV.
Proper truck four-wheel drive — part-time, shift-on-the-fly, with a two-speed transfer case and a genuine 2.717:1 low range giving a 54.4:1 crawl ratio — is available on every King Cab and Crew Cab grade for 2023, standard on PRO-4X and standard on all four Titan XD trims, with an electronic locking rear differential on the off-road grade and an Active Brake Limited-Slip Differential and Hill Start Assist standard fleet-wide. It falls short of the top band only because rear-wheel drive remains the default on the standard Titan, 4x4 is a cost option on most grades, and there is no full-time or torque-vectoring mode for on-road use.
The PRO-4X is a credible factory off-road grade rather than an appearance package: Bilstein off-road shocks, an electronic locking rear differential, radiator and transfer-case skid plates, Hill Descent Control and 275/70R18 all-terrain tires, with the best geometry in the lineup — a 22.8-degree approach angle against 16–17.6 degrees for the rest of the range, 23.0-degree departure with hitch, and roughly 9.5 inches of clearance at the rear axle. It sits a clear tier below the segment's purpose-built specialists: no Raptor/TRD Pro/ZR2-grade widened track, long-travel suspension or spool-valve damping, no front locker and no disconnecting sway bar, and the approach angle is modest by off-road-trim standards.
One engine, one transmission, no alternatives — the most literal reading of the bottom band's take-it-or-leave-it description. The 5.6L V8 and 9-speed automatic are the entire 2023 lineup across Titan, King Cab and XD: no turbo six, no four-cylinder, no hybrid, no plug-in and no EV. The 5.0L Cummins diesel that once gave the XD a genuine second option was dropped after 2019, so even the heavy-duty variant now differs only in frame and gearing. By 2023 every full-size rival offered at least three powertrains and most offered an electrified one, which is a large part of why Nissan confirmed in August 2023 that it would leave the segment.
2Efficiency & RangeThe Titan's lowest-graded category.0.00F
A single 400 hp naturally aspirated 5.6L V8 with the 9-speed automatic is the entire 2023 lineup — no turbo four, no diesel, no hybrid — so 18 MPG combined is not the thirsty end of a range but the whole story. It is still the weakest gasoline half-ton figure of the model year, though it is a full MPG better than the 2024 Titan's EPA rating and lands the Titan closer to the Tundra than the raw reputation suggests.
City driving is where a large naturally aspirated V8 with no electrification and no meaningful cylinder deactivation pays its heaviest penalty, and 15 MPG puts the Titan near the floor of the truck band. Rivals that shut cylinders, downsize to a turbocharged four or add a hybrid motor all pull clear here; four-wheel drive costs the Titan another MPG over the 2WD's 16.
The highway figure is the Titan's least embarrassing efficiency number — the 2020 refresh's 9-speed automatic gives it a genuinely tall top gear and the big V8 loafs at a steady cruise. It still only matches what turbocharged and hybrid rivals return in mixed driving, and the shorter 3.69:1 axle ratio adopted in 2020 for towing response caps how far it can stretch.
A generous 26-gallon tank does the work here, rescuing the Titan's range from its economy and landing it mid-pack rather than last — a longer legal leg than an F-150 on its standard 23-gallon tank. Rivals nonetheless offer 30-plus-gallon extended-range tanks that push past 600 miles, and the Titan has no such option at any trim.
This is the worst figure on the Titan's scorecard and it compounds two penalties: among the lowest combined MPG in the segment multiplied by premium-grade fuel that rivals do not ask for. At roughly 830 gallons of 91-octane a year it runs past the top of the truck band outright — the EPA's own label puts the PRO-4X $11,250 above the average new vehicle in fuel over five years.
Premium is recommended rather than strictly required — Nissan specifies 91 octane for the rated 400 hp and permits 87 when 91 is unavailable, with the engine controller retarding timing to suit. That is textbook mid-band but sits at the bottom of it: the EPA label itself reads 'Premium Gasoline (Recommended)' and computes the annual cost at premium prices, so the recommendation carries a real and unavoidable running-cost penalty on every trim. There is no regular-fuel engine to step down to, no E85 flex-fuel capability, and no diesel or electrified alternative in the 2023 range.
3SafetyGrades below the middle of the scale.1.65D
NHTSA rates the 2023 Titan Crew Cab — the volume body style — 4 stars overall in both 4x2 and 4x4 form. The frontal result is the weak element (4-star driver, 3-star passenger), side impact is a clean 5 stars front and rear, and rollover splits 4 stars 4x2 / 3 stars 4x4 as expected for a tall body-on-frame half-ton.
No Top Safety Pick of any kind, but the published 2023 rating set is mostly Good: driver-side small overlap Good, moderate overlap front (original) Good, roof strength Good, head restraints & seats Good, with passenger-side small overlap the one Acceptable. Two things hold it in the middle band — the frontal ratings were assigned from tests Nissan ran itself on 2020/2021 trucks rather than IIHS-conducted tests, and the 2016-generation structure has no result under the updated moderate overlap or updated side protocols, so the harder modern tests are simply unvalidated. Poor headlights independently disqualify it from any award.
Nissan Safety Shield 360 is standard on every 2023 trim including the base S — AEB with pedestrian detection, blind spot warning, rear cross traffic alert, lane departure warning, high beam assist and rear automatic braking — plus standard Intelligent Forward Collision Warning, which is more standard active-safety content than a base Silverado or Ram carries. Two real gaps keep it out of the top band: Intelligent Cruise Control is not offered at all on the S trim (it appears as '-', not even optional, and becomes standard only from SV up), and there is no lane keep assist or lane centering anywhere in the lineup at any price — only a warning.
The standard system earns IIHS Superior on both front crash prevention tests published for the 2023 truck — vehicle-to-vehicle and daytime vehicle-to-pedestrian — which is a genuinely strong result on standard-on-every-trim hardware and better than several full-size rivals manage. It falls short of the top band because the vehicle-to-vehicle Superior was earned under the older protocol (the rating applies to 2020-23 and was not re-run under the tougher test IIHS introduced for 2022+), and there is no nighttime pedestrian result at all.
Blind spot warning and rear cross traffic alert are standard on all four 2023 trims, and standard rear automatic braking adds real intervention behind the truck rather than an alert alone. What is missing is exactly what matters most in this segment — no trailer-aware blind-spot zone extension of the kind Ford and GM offer on their half-tons — and the side alerts themselves are warning-only with no steering intervention.
The 2023 Titan offers Lane Departure Warning with a haptic steering-wheel vibration and nothing beyond it — no lane keep assist that steers the truck back, and no lane centering on any trim including the $60k Platinum Reserve. Every domestic full-size rival offers at least active lane keeping and most offer centering, making this the clearest single ADAS deficit on the truck.
Radar Intelligent Cruise Control is standard from the SV up — so the volume trim has it without a package upsell — and it operates down to a full stop behind a stopped lead vehicle, though it cancels rather than holding and auto-resuming in stop-and-go traffic. Two things keep it mid-band: it is entirely unavailable on the base S trim, and without any lane centering there is no highway assist to combine it with, leaving the Titan's ACC a solo longitudinal system that reviewers describe as usable but dated next to a 2023 F-150 or Tundra.
No hands-free highway system of any kind. The Titan never received ProPILOT Assist, let alone a hands-off tier, and in 2023 it was competing against half-tons shipping BlueCruise and Super Cruise — Nissan confirmed the truck's discontinuation in August 2023 without ever adding one.
IIHS rates the 2023 Titan's headlights Poor on both available systems — the halogen reflector units on S and SV and the LED projector units on PRO-4X and Platinum Reserve — so there is no way to buy your way out of it. The LED setup shows better straightaway low-beam reach but still throws excessive glare, and neither system is curve-adaptive. Standard high beam assist does not offset a Poor low beam, and this result alone is what keeps the truck out of Top Safety Pick contention despite four Good crashworthiness ratings.
The Titan gives the commanding forward view the segment expects, but reviewers are blunt that the blind spots are huge — thick roof pillars and large rear headrests block the rearward and rear-three-quarter sightlines even with the big convex mirrors. Camera compensation is badly distributed for a volume buyer: the Intelligent Around View Monitor 360-degree system is unavailable on both S and SV, optional on PRO-4X, and standard only on the $60k+ Platinum Reserve, leaving the volume trim with a rearview monitor and rear sonar — the segment floor rather than a fix.
The Crew Cab has a standard LATCH system with upper tether anchors and child safety rear door locks, and the rear doors open wide onto a flat floor, so installations are workable. It stays out of the top band because the rear compartment is genuinely tight by full-size standards — the crew cab's rear legroom is the smallest among its direct competitors — which makes three-across and rear-facing installs behind a tall driver a squeeze. IIHS publishes no LATCH ease-of-use rating for the 2023 Titan.
4Space & ComfortMid-pack among this car's ten categories.1.92C-
The volume 2023 configuration — the SV Crew Cab — comes standard with a 40/20/40 split front bench, so its maximum capacity is six, the ceiling of the truck band. Buyers who option the front buckets, or step up to PRO-4X or Platinum Reserve, get a five-seat cabin instead.
41.0 inches is a genuinely airy front cabin and Nissan publishes one figure for the 2023 Crew Cab across S, SV, PRO-4X and Platinum Reserve; the optional dual-panel panoramic moonroof is not called out as reducing it. Unchanged from the 2020 refresh.
41.8 inches is adequate but sits near the bottom of the full-size truck band, where rivals stretch past 44 inches — the Titan's cab dates to the mid-2010s and never received the front-seat stretch its Detroit competition got. Tall drivers notice the shortfall well before rear passengers do.
40.4 inches of second-row headroom is near the top of the truck band and one of the Titan's real strengths — the upright roofline gives back-seat passengers more clearance than the front row of many crossovers. The King Cab gives up nearly two inches under its shorter rear roof.
38.5 inches seats adults comfortably but lands mid-band and trails the class benchmarks badly — a 2023 F-150 SuperCrew offers 43.6 in and a Ram 1500 Crew Cab 45.2 in, so the Titan gives up roughly half a foot of rear stretch-out to the trucks it is priced against. The King Cab's 24.8 in is why Nissan positions it as a two-plus-occasional truck.
The volume Crew Cab is locked to the 67.0-inch short bed — unlike an F-150 or Silverado crew cab, which can be ordered with a 6.5-ft box, the Titan Crew Cab offers no longer bed at all, and the 8-ft box that anchors the top of the segment band was dropped with the second generation. Buyers who need bed length have to give up the full-size rear seat and take the King Cab.
Nissan publishes bed length but no Crew Cab volume figure, so the 5.5-ft box is derived: scaling the published 59.6 cu ft long-bed figure by bed length (67.0/78.7) gives ~50.7, and the geometric check on 67.0 × 63.8 × 20.8 in gives ~51.5 — the two agree closely. Either way the short box is well under the ~53 cu ft an F-150 SuperCrew's 5.5-ft bed holds and among the smallest cargo boxes in the full-size class.
The fundamentals are present — a deep console bin, flip-up rear seat cushions over configurable under-seat storage, fold-down rear seatbacks with locking backs, a locking glovebox, four bottle holders and available 120-volt outlets in cabin and bed — plus the Utili-track bed channel system with two movable aluminum cleats and the accessory lockable in-bed TITAN Box, which are genuinely good ideas. What is missing is the innovation tier the segment moved to during this generation: no in-bed trunk as standard equipment, no multifunction tailgate, no fold-flat load floor and no Pro Power-style onboard generator. The volume SV is also thin as it sits: the front center console, external console pockets, rear 120-volt outlet, rear USB ports and Utili-track are all cost options on SV and unavailable on the base S, which makes do with 4 front and 2 rear cupholders.
Seats are the Titan's most consistently praised comfort attribute — Edmunds' 2023 review calls the front chairs 'cushy and supportive,' and Nissan's Zero Gravity front seat design draws owner praise for long-haul comfort. The rear bench is flatter and more upright than the class best, and adjustability is thin at the volume end: the 2023 SV's driver seat is 4-way manual with no power, no lumbar and no heating unless the SV Convenience Package is ordered, so the strongest praise really attaches to PRO-4X and Platinum Reserve with 8-way power, power lumbar and memory.
Composed rather than plush. On smooth pavement the Titan settles nicely and absorbs cracks and expansion joints without unsettling the cabin, helped by its heavy curb weight, but the multi-leaf solid rear axle gets busy and skittish over broken surfaces with an empty bed — the classic unladen half-ton trade the coil-sprung Ram has largely engineered out. PRO-4X's Bilstein monotube shocks add off-road body control without softening the on-road secondary ride. Reviewers land on 'mediocre' about as often as 'smooth,' which is what keeps this mid-band.
The weakest comfort attribute and the one reviewers raise unprompted. The blunt front end generates real wind rush at highway speed — enough that testers report raising their voices to hold a conversation — and the climate system's ventilation fan is loud enough to add a constant noise floor even at rest. Nissan lists no acoustic laminated glass or active noise cancellation on any 2023 trim, and the 5.6-liter V8 gets vocal under load, so the Titan sits clearly behind the acoustically insulated Detroit half-tons.
Rich at the top, sparse where most 2023 Titans sell. Platinum Reserve gets dual-zone automatic climate, heated and cooled front seats, heated rear seats, a heated steering wheel and standard remote engine start, and PRO-4X can be optioned to match — but the volume SV Crew Cab ships with single-zone manual climate, no heated seats, no heated wheel and no rear vents, all of which are bundled into the cost-option SV Convenience Package. The 2023 lineup still includes the base S grade, where dual-zone climate, rear vents, heated seats and remote start are simply unavailable. Notably, remote engine start is standard only on Platinum Reserve for 2023 and is an option on SV and PRO-4X — Nissan made it standard across the range only for the final 2024 model year, so 2023 rates a notch below its successor.
5Cost of OwnershipGrades below the middle of the scale.1.59D
2023 still offered the S grade — dropped for 2024 — so the Titan's entry point is a King Cab 4x2 work truck, roughly $6,000 above a base F-150 XL but with V8 power and Safety Shield 360 standard rather than optional. No regular cab or six-cylinder exists below it, which is why the floor sits high for the segment.
Titan volume sits on the SV Crew Cab 4x4, with the new-for-2023 Midnight Edition appearance package the common add on that trim. It lands a few thousand under a comparably equipped Tundra SR5 CrewMax 4x4 or Sierra Elevation, and street pricing ran further below MSRP — Titan inventory carried heavy incentives through 2023 as segment share kept shrinking.
Published estimates straddle a wide range — CarEdge models about $3,069 across five years and puts Titan maintenance $1,635 below the pickup average, while Edmunds True Cost to Own is nearer $6,500 — so this sits between them, tilted low because Nissan's 60-month/100,000-mile basic coverage absorbs nearly every unscheduled repair in the window, where the domestic rivals' bumper-to-bumper stops at 3 yr/36,000 mi. Working the other way: the 5.6-liter Endurance V8 takes a large synthetic fill, nothing is prepaid, and Nissan's August 2023 announcement that the Titan ends after 2024 thins dealer service volume later in the ownership period.
Depreciation is the Titan's defining ownership weakness and by far the biggest drag on this category. Independent residual models converge just above 50%, well behind the full-size pickup class average and far behind a Tundra's mid-60s — thin brand demand, an aging platform and heavy new-car incentives all compound. A 2023 truck is also hit by Nissan's August 2023 confirmation that the nameplate dies after 2024, which arrived barely a year into this model year's life and removed any residual support from a future generation.
Best in the segment by a wide margin: every domestic full-size rival and the Tundra stop bumper-to-bumper at 3 years/36,000 miles, so the Titan carries two extra years and nearly triple the mileage. Tires, corrosion and federal/California emissions items are excluded as usual.
Five years is the floor of the normalization band and scores accordingly, but the years figure understates what is actually covered: the 100,000-mile cap doubles the 5 yr/60,000 mi powertrain terms on the F-150, Silverado, Sierra and Ram 1500, and the Titan's full bumper-to-bumper coverage runs the entire same period rather than expiring at year three.
No complimentary scheduled maintenance at all — the first oil change is the owner's, where ToyotaCare covers a 2023 Tundra for 2 years/25,000 miles and GM includes a first-visit service on the Silverado and Sierra. What the Titan does have is the longest included roadside assistance in the segment: 60 months/100,000 miles, matching the warranty term rather than the 36 months/36,000 miles other Nissans get, plus a NissanConnect Services trial and available Nissan Concierge (paid subscription). Better than 'basic roadside only', short of anything prepaid, so it sits on the boundary between the two bands.
$50,335 volume-trim price minus its estimated resale value after 5 years (51% retained, or about $25,671) leaves about $24,664 in depreciation. Add the projected $5,400 in 5-year maintenance and repairs, and owning this vehicle for 5 years costs about $30,064 in total.
6Reliability & QualityThe Titan's best-graded category.2.71B-
2023 is the Titan's high-water mark for predicted dependability and the single best argument for the truck. J.D. Power scored the 2023 model 88/100 — inside its "Great" band and the highest mark of any full-size or mid-size pickup that model year, ahead of the Sierra 1500 at 84 and the Tundra at 78. The mechanical explanation is straightforward: by 2023 the A61 is an eight-year-old design carrying a naturally aspirated V8 and a conventional torque-converter automatic, with no turbocharging, no cylinder deactivation, no hybrid hardware and no CVT to generate warranty claims. It stops short of the 80s because Titan volume is a small fraction of its rivals' so the survey sample is thin, Consumer Reports places the brand only mid-pack, and RepairPal notes that when repairs do come they are rated more severe than the class norm.
Nissan's brand standing in the 2023 studies is mid-pack but pointed upward, which is why this sits a few points above the 57 used elsewhere in the dataset. J.D. Power's 2023 Vehicle Dependability Study put Nissan tied 9th at 170 problems per 100 vehicles — better than the 186 PP100 industry average — and named it one of the three most-improved brands, up 35 PP100 year over year. Consumer Reports pulls the other way at 17th. Note that essentially all of Nissan's reputational damage traces to Xtronic CVT passenger cars and crossovers, hardware the Titan shares none of, but this item scores the brand rather than the drivetrain.
Exactly two NHTSA campaigns attach to the 2023 model year, which is a light load by full-size-truck standards where rival trucks have fielded engine-replacement and six-figure software campaigns. Neither involves a hardware failure of the engine, transmission, frame or fuel system: the parking-pawl campaign is remedied by a control-module reflash and the tire recall is a supplier bead defect fixed by replacing the road tires. It does not score higher because a rollaway risk is a serious defect class regardless of how cheap the fix is, and because a truck selling in Titan volumes has far fewer units in the field to surface defects, so a short recall list carries less statistical weight than the same list on an F-150.
The strongest item on the scorecard. The 5.6-liter VK56VD "Endurance" V8 is a long-running naturally aspirated design shared with the Armada and Infiniti QX56/QX80, with a well-established high-mileage record and none of the turbochargers, cylinder deactivation or belt-driven hybrid motors that create failure modes on rival full-size trucks. The nine-speed Jatco automatic introduced with the 2020 refresh was in its fourth model year by 2023 and draws shift-quality complaints rather than failure reports — a real but minor deduction, alongside the fact that the 22V671 parking-pawl campaign was a transmission-control software defect on this same unit. The first generation's transmission-cooler contamination history belongs to the A60 truck and does not apply here.
The clear weak point, and it lands below the mid band because this item measures richness relative to price. The A61 cabin was already a generation behind when the 2020 refresh left most of it untouched, and by 2023 it was being sold against Ram and Silverado interiors at fifty thousand dollars for the volume crew cab. Reviewers are close to unanimous that hard plastic dominates the cabin even in upper trims, and that the Titan trails most rivals on cabin materials outright. It earns a couple of points over the 2024 truck only because the higher trims do dress the dash and doors with soft materials and wood accents, and the volume trim's sticker is marginally lower.
Assembly quality sits well above perceived material quality. The A61 was in its eighth model year on a mature body-on-frame line at Canton, Mississippi, and owner reports for the 2023 truck consistently describe a solid, rattle-free structure at 35,000 to 55,000 miles rather than the squeaks and misalignment that would drop this into the penalty band; J.D. Power's 2023 APEAL study also put the Titan first among large light-duty pickups on owner-assessed execution after 90 days. It stays mid-band rather than higher because APEAL measures appeal rather than defects, Consumer Reports still calls the interior fit and finish lackluster, and scattered owner complaints about paint and the infotainment system persist.
The strongest service-side result in the dataset for this brand, and it is specific to this model year: J.D. Power's 2023 Customer Service Index named Nissan the No. 1 truck brand for dealership service satisfaction at 886 of 1,000 points, 48 points clear of the segment average and highest in all five factors measured. Layer that on roughly a thousand US franchises — genuinely nationwide coverage including the rural markets a work truck lives in — and 2023 buyers got both reach and quality. It scores above the Frontier's 72 and well above the 2024 Titan's 66 for that reason, and stops short of the top band only because 2023 is the second-to-last Titan: Nissan confirmed in August 2023, during this model year's sales run, that it was exiting the full-size segment, so technician familiarity with a low-volume V8 truck thins as the fleet ages.
Running costs are genuinely low. RepairPal puts the Titan's average annual repair and maintenance bill at roughly 40 percent below the full-size truck average, helped by a body-on-frame layout with cheap wear items and a V8 shared with the Armada and Infiniti QX80, which keeps engine components in production well past the truck itself. Nissan's 5-year/100,000-mile bumper-to-bumper coverage — the longest in the segment and marketed as America's Best Truck Warranty — also absorbs most unscheduled repair inside a typical ownership window. It does not score higher because the Titan never reached a quarter of its 100,000-unit annual sales target, so the aftermarket is a fraction of the F-150's or Silverado's, body panels and trim are effectively dealer-only, and the nameplate's 2024 discontinuation means model-specific parts get scarcer as the fleet ages.
7Technology & InfotainmentOne of the Titan's weakest categories.1.27D
The 2023 Titan's volume trim is the SV, which carries an 8.0-inch color display with multi-touch control as standard. Unlike 2024, the 9.0-inch Integrated Command Center is not even optional on the volume grade in 2023 — it is standard-only equipment on PRO-4X and Platinum Reserve. Scored on the 8.0-inch unit per the volume-trim rule, which sits at the very floor of the full-size-truck normalization band.
NissanConnect on the Titan is genuinely easy to operate — real volume and tuning knobs, large labelled HVAC buttons, and a shallow menu structure — and reviewers credit the 9-inch unit's crisp graphics and quick response. The drag is age: the A61 architecture dates to 2016, and by 2023 the standard 8.0-inch SV display is among the smallest and lowest-resolution head units in the full-size class. Scored a point above the otherwise-identical 2024 truck because the same hardware was one model year less dated.
Wireless Apple CarPlay was the headline 2023 technology change, but it landed only on PRO-4X and Platinum Reserve — the volume SV keeps wired CarPlay, and Android Auto is wired on every grade with no wireless option at any price. That is textbook "wired standard, wireless on upper trims," and one platform never going wireless holds it to the lower half of that band.
The volume SV Crew Cab has neither built-in navigation nor Nissan Voice Recognition, and in 2023 there is no way to buy either on that grade — both are tied to the 9-inch Integrated Command Center, which is PRO-4X/Platinum Reserve equipment. Even where fitted, the assistant is command-list based rather than natural-language, so owners default to phone-projected maps.
A 6-speaker display-audio system is standard, and the available Fender-powered 12-speaker system — branded amplifier, under-seat subwoofer, center channel and front/rear tweeters — is a legitimately strong premium upgrade for a mainstream truck, comparable to Bose in the GM trucks and B&O in the F-150. Held back by an unremarkable base six-speaker setup and by the Fender system being package- or top-trim-only.
Every 2023 Titan gets a 7.0-inch programmable color driver-information display flanked by analog Fine Vision dials, standard across all grades — better than rivals that gate any color cluster display behind an upgrade. But it is a partial-digital setup: no full-digital gauge cluster is offered at any price, so there is no path to what the F-150, Silverado and Ram all provide.
There is no whole-vehicle over-the-air update programme on the Titan. Nissan's OTA scope covers the NissanConnect head unit's own software and, on nav-equipped trims, map data — 2023 did move head-unit updates from USB-stick to Wi-Fi/embedded delivery, which is why it edges the 2024 score by a point in capability terms, but no feature-adding vehicle software reaches the truck. On the volume SV the connected map updates are absent entirely because NissanConnect with Navigation is not available on that grade.
NissanConnect Services covers the expected core set — remote start/stop, remote lock/unlock, vehicle locator and alerts — through the MyNISSAN app on a new-vehicle trial that converts to a paid subscription. Two things hold it back: there is no phone-as-key of any kind, and on the volume SV Crew Cab the connected-services hardware is an option bundled into the Convenience Package rather than standard equipment.
Front ports are thin but modern enough for the era — two illuminated USB (one Type-A, one Type-C) standard on every grade — and the truck's real strength is household power: a rear 120-volt cabin outlet plus an available in-bed 120-volt outlet, which matters more on a work truck than port count. Against it, no Qi wireless charging pad exists at any trim or price in 2023 (only a mechanical "dedicated cell phone holder"), and the rear charge-only USB-A pair and rear 120V outlet are both optional on the volume SV.
Remote keyless entry with a multi-function fob (windows-lowering, two-driver memory) and push-button ignition are standard, but the proximity Intelligent Key with driver and passenger request switches is a Convenience Package item on the volume SV Crew Cab, and remote engine start is likewise optional on SV and PRO-4X and standard only on Platinum Reserve. No phone-as-key is offered; being a pickup there is no hands-free liftgate, and the electronically-locking tailgate is itself a package item.
Squarely mid-band: a RearView Monitor and rear sonar are standard on S, SV and PRO-4X, front-and-rear sonar is available, and the Intelligent Around View Monitor with Moving Object Detection — a 360-degree system Nissan marketed as class-exclusive — is optional on PRO-4X and standard on Platinum Reserve. Camera resolution is dated 2016-era hardware and there is no automated parking of any kind.
No head-up display was ever offered on the second-generation Titan, and 2023 is no exception — it appears on no grade, in no package, and on no accessory list. Scored in the low band for outright absence.
8Use-Case FitOne of the Titan's strongest categories.2.04C
The Crew Cab gives families four full-size doors, a 60/40 rear bench whose cushions flip up and whose seatbacks fold down and lock for in-cabin gear, and complete LATCH sets with upper tether anchors and rear door child locks standard on every grade. The measurements are what hold it back: 38.5 in of rear legroom is the tightest back seat among full-size crew cabs (F-150 SuperCrew and Sierra Crew both offer 43.6 in), and a 23.9 in rear step-in height on a 4x4 SV means small children get lifted in rather than climbing in.
Nissan Safety Shield 360 — automatic emergency braking with pedestrian detection, blind-spot warning, rear cross-traffic alert, rear automatic braking, lane departure warning and high-beam assist — plus Rear Door Alert and a rear sonar system are standard on every 2023 grade including the base S, which is exactly the content families shop for and better than several rivals gate behind trim walls. The credentials underneath are weaker: 4 stars overall from NHTSA, IIHS-rated Poor halogen headlights on the S and SV trims families actually buy, no lane keeping or centering assist at all, and Intelligent Cruise Control absent on the base S.
Rear passengers get 38.5 in of legroom on a flat-ish bench with a flip-down center armrest, reading lamps, coat hangers and four bottle holders, and on PRO-4X and Platinum Reserve two illuminated USB charging ports, a rear 120-volt outlet and rear A/C vents. On the volume SV all of those rear amenities live inside the Convenience Package, the base S cannot get rear vents or rear power at any price, luggage rides in an open 5.5-ft bed unless a tonneau is added, and reviewers consistently flag ambient cabin noise at highway speed.
The naturally aspirated 5.6L Endurance V8 is the Titan's commuting asset — 400 hp delivered linearly with no turbo lag or low-speed hesitation behind a 9-speed torque-converter automatic — and press and owner reviews describe a smooth, composed ride that absorbs cracked pavement without upsetting the cabin. Against that, Edmunds calls the steering 'surprisingly heavy and cumbersome in a way that hinders maneuverability at low speed', the cabin carries constant ambient noise, and a 22.0 in front step-in height on a 4x4 is a climb twice a day.
Commuting is the Titan's worst use case: 18 MPG combined with premium gasoline recommended works out to an EPA-estimated $4,200 a year in fuel, materially above what a Silverado or Sierra 5.3L V8 costs at similar economy on regular unleaded, because the fuel itself is dearer. There is no hybrid, diesel or electrified option to soften it — the 5.0L Cummins left after 2019 and the gas V8 is the whole lineup — though 2023 does rate one MPG better combined than the 2024 truck, which trims the annual bill by about $250.
At 228.2 in long and 79.5 in wide on a 139.8-in wheelbase the SV Crew Cab is squarely full-size, and while its 48.0-ft wall-to-wall turning circle is no worse than the class norm, reviewers single out the heavy, low-geared steering as a liability in parking lots. The camera and sensor help that makes a truck this size manageable is badly gated: only a RearView Monitor and rear sonar are standard, front-and-rear sonar is optional below Platinum Reserve, and the Intelligent Around View 360-degree monitor is simply unavailable on the S and the volume SV.
The 400-hp V8 pulls well and 9,323 lbs of towing is real capability, but both headline numbers are the lowest in the full-size half-ton class by a wide gap — F-150 reaches 13,500 lbs, Sierra 13,300, Tundra 12,000 — and a 1,697 lb maximum payload is mid-size-truck territory that a pallet of block or a bed of gravel will exhaust. The Crew Cab compounds it with a single 5.5-ft bed; buyers needing more must take the King Cab's 6.5-ft box or step to the separate Titan XD, which tows 11,033 lbs with a gooseneck and carries 2,406 lbs.
Mechanically the Titan is the conservative pick for hard use — a naturally aspirated 5.6L V8 with no turbochargers on a fully boxed ladder frame behind a torque-converter 9-speed, backed by 5-year/100,000-mile bumper-to-bumper AND powertrain coverage that no domestic rival matches, plus a top-of-class J.D. Power quality score. What it lacks is the fleet track record this item grades at the top: the Titan never reached meaningful commercial volume, and Nissan confirmed in August 2023 — during this model year's sales run — that it would exit the full-size segment after 2024, which raises legitimate long-term parts-and-service questions for a hard-use buyer.
The Utili-track channel system — three bed rails with two lockable aluminum cleats that slide to wherever the load actually sits — remains the best factory bed-management hardware in the class, alongside four fixed tie-downs standard on every grade, a 120-volt in-bed outlet, four-source LED bed and tailgate lighting, spray-in bedliner, a damped removable tailgate, an electronic locking tailgate, a rear utility bed step and lockable in-bed TITAN Boxes. Two things hold it back: on the volume SV nearly all of it is bundled into the Utility Package and the base S cannot order Utili-track, cleats, in-bed power or bed lighting at all, and there is no multifunction tailgate or high-output onboard generator to answer Ford's Pro Power Onboard.
A 26.0-gallon tank at 18 MPG combined gives an EPA total range of 468 miles — a genuine day of driving between stops and 26 miles better than the 2024 truck — and the front seats draw consistent praise as cushy and supportive over multi-hour stints, with Intelligent Cruise Control standard from SV up. The fatigue-reduction story stops there: the Titan offers only lane departure warning with no lane keep or centering, so the driver steers every mile, and reviewers repeatedly flag ambient cabin noise at highway speed.
PRO-4X is a real off-road trim rather than a decal package: Bilstein off-road shocks, an electronic locking rear differential, hill descent control, radiator and transfer-case skid plates and 275/70R18 all-terrain tires on a 4x4 chassis with 10.6 in of front ground clearance, a 22.8-degree approach angle and a 21.7-degree breakover angle. Camping is well served by the 120-volt bed outlet, four-source bed lighting, a sports bar and accessory protection packages — but 9,323 lbs of towing limits which toys come along, and there is no front locker, disconnecting sway bar or 33-inch-tire halo variant of the sort Tundra TRD Pro and F-150 Raptor offer.
Inside, the rear bench flips up and its seatbacks fold down and lock over a flat-floor function with tie-down hooks and a divided, lockable storage box; outside, the Utili-track cleats let tie-down points move to the load instead of living at four fixed corners, with lockable TITAN Boxes, a receiver hitch with 4-pin/7-pin wiring and a rear utility bed step available. The ceiling on it is the bed itself — the Crew Cab is offered only with a 5.5-ft box, the shortest single option in the full-size class, where every domestic rival lets a buyer step up to a 6.5-ft or 8-ft bed; the 6.5-ft box requires giving up the back seat for a King Cab.
9Driving ExperienceOne of the Titan's strongest categories.2.14C
2023 is a carry-over year in the second-generation (A61) Titan, a 2016 chassis whose last meaningful suspension work was the 2020 refresh — and it is the least composed of the conventional full-size trucks. The double-wishbone front / multi-leaf solid-axle rear setup delivers pronounced body roll and a light, hoppy rear end with the bed empty, and reviewers uniformly rank it behind the F-150 and Ram 1500. It stays secure and predictable rather than nervous, so it lands in the lower half of the 50-79 'secure but unremarkable' band, below Silverado 1500 (62) and Tundra (62.5) but clear of the buckboard Gladiator (58.9) on ride composure.
The standard Titan's engine-speed-variable rack-and-pinion (16:1, 3.0 turns lock-to-lock) is heavy without being informative. MotorWeek credits it with 'a good amount of feel,' but the volume of published reviews describe the weight as cumbersome rather than communicative, with the truck wandering on the highway and the heft actively hurting low-speed maneuvering — which, paired with the 48-foot turning circle, makes the Titan feel larger than it is in parking lots. That split verdict puts it at the bottom of the 50-79 'precise enough but numb' band.
The Titan's best dynamic attribute. Four-wheel vented discs are standard on every 2023 trim — 13.78-inch front and 13.58-inch rear rotors on the Titan, larger still on the XD — with 4-wheel/4-channel ABS, EBD and brake assist. Instrumented stops from 60 mph average 128 feet, a genuinely good figure for a ~5,700-lb full-size pickup, and the pedal is firm rather than the long, soft travel that afflicts several rivals. Scored at the top of the 50-79 band rather than into the 80s because there is no published fade or repeat-stop data and no towing-specific brake testing to confirm it holds up loaded.
The Titan's other real strength, and a case where being behind the technological curve pays off. Every 2023 truck runs the naturally aspirated 5.6L Endurance V8 (400 hp / 413 lb-ft) with the nine-speed Jatco automatic adopted in the 2020 refresh: no turbo lag, no hybrid handoff to fumble, no cylinder-deactivation shudder and no stop/start restart to feel. Tip-in is linear and the transmission holds the right gear on grades. Held short of the 80s because the truck feels sluggish off the line for its power — 7.5 s to 60 mph, roughly a second behind a V8 F-150 — so response lags the smoothness.
The 5.6L V8 has a deep, slightly raspy character under load that most reviewers like — no coarse turbo-four thrash, no four-cylinder drone at cruise — but the Titan's cabin isolation is a 2016 design that was never a class benchmark and has since been leapfrogged by the fully redesigned F-150, Silverado and Tundra. The engine is more present in the cabin than it needs to be and wind and road noise intrude more at highway speed, which keeps it mid-band despite the pleasant engine note.
A weakness reviewers name directly. Every 2023 Titan uses the same 139.8-inch wheelbase whether Crew Cab or King Cab, so unlike the F-150, Silverado or Tundra there is no short-wheelbase or short-bed configuration that turns tighter — the volume truck and the long-bed truck turn identically badly. At 48.0 ft it sits in the upper half of the 40-54 ft truck band, and the heavy steering effort makes the arc feel worse than the number reads.
Comfortably better than the Titan's dynamics. Nissan's Zero Gravity front seats are among the segment's most comfortable for long stints and draw top marks from Car and Driver, the tall squared-off greenhouse gives a commanding view out, and the dash retains physical climate and audio controls rather than burying them in the touchscreen. Tilt-and-telescoping steering (manual on S/SV, power on upper trims) covers most builds. Kept out of the 80s by the older cabin architecture, the high step-in without running boards on lower trims, and thicker pillars than the recently redesigned rivals.
What character the 2023 Titan has comes from the engine: a 400-hp naturally aspirated V8 standard on every trim is increasingly rare in a half-ton, it pulls with a good rumble, and the PRO-4X has genuine off-road appeal with its locking rear diff and hill descent control. Everything around it is inert — numb heavy steering, roly handling, a 48-ft turning circle, an eight-year-old cabin — so it is pleasant and honest rather than something you take the long way home in. Mid-band, comfortably below the Ram 1500 (69.5) and F-150 (64.9).
10Value & Market PositionGrades below the middle of the scale.1.31D
Two things are genuinely generous and both are standard on every 2023 grade: the 400 hp / 413 lb-ft 5.6L Endurance V8 with the 9-speed automatic — Nissan's 'most standard horsepower in its class' claim is legitimate, and there is no penalty-box base engine the way an F-150 XL gets a 3.3L V6 — and Nissan Safety Shield 360, a six-system suite (automatic emergency braking with pedestrian detection, blind-spot warning, rear cross-traffic alert, lane-departure warning, high-beam assist, rear automatic braking) plus class-exclusive Intelligent Forward Collision Warning, on the $39,950 S as well as the $62,230 Platinum Reserve. Add an 8-inch touchscreen with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto on all grades and the 5 yr/100,000 mi bumper-to-bumper warranty and the floor is high. What keeps it mid-band is what the volume SV Crew Cab still does without at $48,440: halogen headlights (LEDs are a PRO-4X/Platinum item), a manually adjustable cloth seat, a manual sliding rear window, no built-in navigation and no tow package — line items rivals include or bundle cheaply at that money. Slightly ahead of the 2024 truck, which deleted the S grade and its well-equipped-for-the-money entry point.
Better value than the run-out 2024 truck, and fair rather than poor against the class. The 2023 entry point is the argument for it: an S Crew Cab 4x2 at $44,930 delivered ($43,635 for the 4x2, $41,845 for an S King Cab) buys the full 400 hp V8, the nine-speed, Safety Shield 360 and a 5 yr/100,000 mi warranty against 3 yr/36,000 mi on every domestic rival — that is a lot of hardware for the money, and the $64,125 Platinum Reserve undercuts a comparably loaded F-150 Limited or Sierra Denali Ultimate by five figures. The drags are structural: the volume SV Crew Cab 4x4 lands at $50,335 delivered, priced against an F-150 XLT or Silverado LT while topping out at 9,323 lbs of tow (vs 13,500 for an F-150) and ~1,700 lbs of payload, and returning 15/21/18 MPG on recommended premium — roughly $4,200 a year in fuel. And the discount never survives ownership: the Titan sheds 48.3% over five years against a 42.5% full-size-pickup average, so the sticker advantage is repaid at trade-in.
Meaningfully broader than the three-grade 2024 lineup but still the narrowest offering among full-size trucks. For 2023 Nissan sold four grades — S, SV, PRO-4X, Platinum Reserve — across two cabs and both drivelines: eleven standard-Titan configurations from a $39,950 S King Cab 4x2 to a $62,230 Platinum Reserve Crew Cab 4x4, plus four heavy-duty Titan XD Crew Cab 4x4 grades ($47,590–$65,320) on the longer frame. That is a real budget ladder. What holds it below the middle is that there is exactly one powertrain — no diesel since 2019, no hybrid, no six-cylinder, one axle setup — no regular cab since the 2020 refresh, and a single bed length per cab (5.5-ft Crew, 6.5-ft King). A buyer who wants a work-spec regular cab, a long bed or a different engine has nothing to pick. Against an F-150 with five powertrains, three cabs, three bed lengths and seven-plus trims, or a Silverado with eight trims, the flexibility that defines this segment simply isn't there.
A distant last in the segment, with a rebound that flatters the trend line. Nissan sold 15,889 Titans in the US in 2023 — up 25.2% on 2022's supply-constrained 12,687, but still barely half of the 31,514 moved in 2019 and well under a fifth of the fourth-place Tundra. Including the XD the nameplate managed roughly 19,189 units against more than 750,000 F-Series, under 3% of Ford's volume, and the Titan was only Nissan's eighth best-selling model with the Frontier outselling it three to one. Nissan targeted 100,000 annual US sales and a 5% segment share when the A61 launched for 2016 and peaked at 21,880 that first year. The market's verdict was delivered inside this model year: Nissan confirmed in August 2023 that it would exit the full-size segment after 2024, having already pulled the Titan from Canada after MY2021.
Nissan is a neutral mainstream badge overall, but the full-size pickup is the most brand-loyal purchase in the US market and there the badge works against the truck rather than being neutral. The segment is defined by three domestic nameplates with decades of accumulated jobsite credibility plus Toyota's separately earned durability reputation; a Nissan pickup carries none of that with the towing-and-hauling buyer, and by August 2023 the announced segment exit told anyone still shopping that Nissan itself had stopped believing in it. Scored slightly above the 2024 truck because for most of the 2023 selling year the Titan was not yet a confirmed dead model. What keeps it well out of the bottom band is that the people who actually buy one are happy: the Titan was named most appealing Large Light Duty Pickup in the J.D. Power 2023 US APEAL Study, beating the F-150 and Silverado on owner experience. The image problem is one of consideration, not of disappointment after purchase.
Scored as buyer benefit, this is the category's strongest item. Slow-moving inventory meant real money on the hood all year — 0% APR for up to 60 months through NMAC on SV, PRO-4X and Platinum Reserve Crew Cabs, stacking with factory cash and loyalty money for existing Nissan/Infiniti owners — and the August 2023 discontinuation announcement turned that into open run-out discounting on a nameplate nobody else was bidding against. A 2023 Titan shopper could routinely transact thousands below sticker at a time when F-150 and Tundra buyers were paying at or near MSRP. It stops short of the top band on two counts: the 0% offer excluded the base S trims, and the same weakness that produces the discount produces the segment's worst residuals, so a meaningful share of the saving is handed back at trade-in.
An aging generation nearing a known end. The A61 Titan launched for MY2016 and took its only significant refresh for MY2020, making 2023 the eighth model year of the generation and the fourth since the update — and a carry-over year at that: the only changes are a cosmetic Midnight Edition package for the Crew Cab SV and wireless CarPlay added to PRO-4X and Platinum Reserve. The hardware underneath is older still: a naturally aspirated V8 whose lineage runs back to 2004-era Nissan trucks, no electrification of any kind, and no over-the-air update capability. Every direct rival was newer inside this window — F-150 redesigned for 2021, Silverado and Sierra substantially refreshed for 2022, Tundra all-new for 2022. Scored a notch above the 2024 truck only because the redesign question was still open for part of the year; Nissan's August 2023 confirmation of the segment exit resolved it in the worst possible way, leaving 2023 buyers with an orphaned nameplate rather than a replacement to wait for.
Reviewers were consistently respectful and consistently unconvinced. Edmunds called it 'a perfectly competent full-size light-duty pickup' that 'doesn't have enough personality to make up for the lack of choice in powertrains, features and body styles,' concluding the F-150, Ram 1500 and Silverado 1500 'are better trucks overall'; US News scored it 7.7/10 and ranked it sixth among 2023 full-size pickups. The Titan has never won a full-size comparison test in this generation and collected no 10Best, NACTOY or Top Pick honors. Two genuine counterweights hold it near the middle of the band rather than the bottom: the J.D. Power 2023 US APEAL Study named it the most appealing Large Light Duty Pickup, ahead of the F-150 and Silverado, and both KBB (4/5) and owners (Edmunds consumer average 4.5/5 across 38 reviews) rate it well. Critics rank it near the back of the class; the people who own one like it.