The verdict
A struggling off-road suv, strong on ownership and held back by safety.
The 2017 Wrangler is the last year of the old-school JK generation, and it drives like it: clumsy on-road handling, a loud cabin, and essentially no driver-assistance safety tech. But nothing at this price matches its 42.2-degree approach angle, locking differentials, and removable doors/roof, and it holds resale value (about 70% after 5 years) better than almost anything else on sale. Buy this one for what it does off-pavement and despite what it does on it — shoppers who mostly drive on highways should look at the tech-laden, better-riding 2018+ JL instead.
Jump to scoresStrengths
- Benchmark off-road hardware
- Class-leading resale value
- Generous open-top cabin space
What holds it back
- Almost no modern safety technology
- Dated, barebones infotainment
- Rough ride and a loud cabin
Top alternatives
Cars shoppers cross-shop with the Jeep Wrangler
1.95C-
Ford BroncoOff-Road SUVBetter at: On-road mannersNearly the same off-road brief with independent front suspension, better steering and a quieter cabin, so it survives the commute far better between trail weekends.
Compare
2.38C+
Toyota 4RunnerOff-Road SUVBetter at: Towing & reliabilityTows 6,000 lb, offers a third row, includes its full safety suite as standard, and carries a reliability reputation the Wrangler can't claim.
Compare
2.43C+
Jeep Grand CherokeeMid-Size SUVBetter at: Comfort & towingThe Jeep to buy when the trail hardware isn't essential — double the tow rating, real ride comfort and a modern driver-assist suite.
CompareHow it's evolved
10 scored model years · 2017–2026
Subject scores by year
Hover or tap a score to see what moved it versus the year before. A corner mark flags a big swing.
| Year | Performance | Efficiency | Safety | Space | Cost | Reliability | Tech | Use-case | Driving | Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 53 | 37 | 55 | 47 | 59 | 62 | 68 | 55 | 54 | 65 |
| 2025 | 58 | 35 | 42 | 44 | 62 | 46 | 64 | 55 | 49 | 68 |
| 2024 | 58 | 35 | 46 | 45 | 60 | 52 | 63 | 55 | 52 | 67 |
| 2023 | 54 | 35 | 41 | 43 | 60 | 53 | 44 | 52 | 51 | 60 |
| 2022 | 52 | 41 | 41 | 43 | 69 | 52 | 45 | 53 | 51 | 64 |
| 2021 | 53 | 41 | 41 | 41 | 52 | 45 | 40 | 46 | 46 | 65 |
| 2020 | 54 | 35 | 40 | 42 | 65 | 56 | 32 | 48 | 48 | 71 |
| 2019 | 49 | 36 | 44 | 44 | 66 | 45 | 34 | 47 | 45 | 72 |
| 2018 | 55 | 38 | 38 | 42 | 66 | 52 | 34 | 51 | 48 | 74 |
| 2017 | 47 | 26 | 14 | 36 | 65 | 57 | 18 | 34 | 38 | 59 |
Compare two years
Best fit & conditions
Higher scores mean a better fit for that use case. Learn more about use-case fit →
Subject profile
Trims & configurations
6 trimsScores above reflect the volume trim. Per-trim specs and scores are rolling out — the full lineup:
Detailed scoring by subject
1Performance & PowertrainGrades below the middle of the scale.1.13D
Sole engine for the 2017 US-market Wrangler; the same 3.6L Pentastar V6 across Sport, Sahara and Rubicon.
Peak torque of the standard 3.6L Pentastar V6, unchanged across trims.
No primary-source (Car and Driver/Motor Trend) instrumented test for MY2017 specifically surfaced; aggregator-sourced figures for Unlimited Sahara/Rubicon automatics cluster in this band, consistent with period tests of the unchanged JK drivetrain.
The Pentastar V6 itself is smooth and torquey with no turbo lag, but period reviews note it works hard to move the Wrangler's boxy, heavy body, and there is no hybrid system to smooth delivery further.
The 2017 Wrangler still uses a dated 5-speed automatic (or 6-speed manual) — one generation behind the ZF 8-speed the JL introduced in 2018 — adequate and predictable but prone to noticeable gear hunting and not class-leading.
Official manufacturer maximum when properly equipped; base config without the tow package/3.73 axle is rated lower.
4WD is standard on every 2017 Wrangler trim (there is no 2WD option), with two distinct systems: Command-Trac (Sport/Sahara, 2.72:1 low range) and Rock-Trac (Rubicon, 4.0:1 low range with front/rear locking diffs and a disconnecting front sway bar) — genuinely sophisticated hardware, not just a badge.
The segment benchmark for off-road credibility: dedicated Rubicon trim with dual Dana 44 axles, front/rear locking differentials, disconnecting front sway bar, 32-in tires, and class-leading approach/breakover/departure angles.
Single powertrain for MY2017 — only the 3.6L Pentastar V6, paired with a 6-speed manual or 5-speed automatic. No 4-cylinder, diesel, hybrid or plug-in option existed on the JK; the 4xe PHEV didn't arrive until the next-generation JL in 2021.
2Efficiency & RangeOne of the Wrangler's weakest categories.0.00F
Same 18 MPG combined EPA rating applies to both body styles and both transmissions for the 3.6L V6 4WD Wrangler.
Unlimited (the higher-volume 4-door body style) rates 16 city; the 2-door rates 17 city on the same drivetrain.
Unlimited automatic rates 20 highway; manual-transmission and 2-door variants rate 21 highway.
Computed from EPA combined MPG and manufacturer fuel tank capacity; the 22.5-gal Unlimited tank figure is EPA-sourced, the 18.6-gal 2-door figure is corroborated by multiple secondary sources but not confirmed directly off fueleconomy.gov in this pass.
EPA's standard annual fuel cost estimate at 15,000 mi/yr and average fuel prices, same for both body styles at 18 MPG combined.
The Pentastar V6 runs on regular unleaded with no premium recommendation, and there is no plug-in charging complexity to weigh.
3SafetyThe Wrangler's lowest-graded category.0.00F
NHTSA tested only rollover (3 stars, both body styles) and frontal (Unlimited 4-door: 3★ driver, 2★ passenger; 2-door: not tested); no side-impact test and no combined overall star rating exists for the JK-generation Wrangler.
Good in both small-overlap and moderate-overlap front tests, but Marginal in the side test with a known concern (driver door opened during the side-impact test) and no standard side airbags for head/chest protection — a real safety gap flagged by IIHS. No Top Safety Pick award.
The 2017 model year is the final year of the JK generation (redesigned JL arrives for 2018), and JK-generation Wranglers offered essentially no advanced driver-assistance systems on any trim — not even as an option.
No forward collision warning or automatic emergency braking system was available on the 2017 Wrangler in any trim, so there is no IIHS front crash prevention rating to speak of.
No factory blind-spot monitoring or rear cross-traffic alert was offered on any 2017 Wrangler trim; JK-generation owners resorted to aftermarket blind-spot mirror/radar kits, underscoring the absence of a factory system.
No lane departure warning or lane keep assist was available on any 2017 Wrangler trim.
Only conventional fixed-speed cruise control was available; adaptive cruise control was not offered on any 2017 Wrangler trim.
No hands-free highway driving system existed on the Wrangler in this era.
IIHS rated the Wrangler's headlights Poor across both trim variants tested, among the worst-performing headlights in the 2017 IIHS headlight study.
The Wrangler's upright windshield, flat hood and slab sides give a commanding view of the vehicle's corners that off-road drivers specifically value for placement, but the hardtop's thick D-pillars, spare tire, and (on the soft top) small rear window meaningfully compromise rear and three-quarter visibility.
On the four-door Wrangler Unlimited, lower LATCH anchors are exposed and straightforward to use and top tethers sit at the base of the seatback, but the tight rear seat forces front-seat occupants to sit far forward with larger convertible seats installed, and the two-door body style requires folding the seat forward entirely to access the rear.
4Space & ComfortGrades near the bottom of the scale.0.39F
Volume trim is the 4-door Unlimited, which seats 5; the 2-door seats 4. Low in the SUV 4-8 band since it caps at 5 with no larger-seating option.
Open-top design gives generous front headroom, above the SUV segment midpoint.
Mid-pack front legroom for the SUV segment band (40-44.5 in).
Boxy upright cabin and open-top design give strong rear headroom near the top of the SUV band.
Rear legroom sits in the middle of the SUV band, adequate for the 4-door but not class-leading.
The Wrangler Unlimited is strictly a two-row, 5-seat SUV with no third-row option on any trim in 2017.
Behind-second-row cargo volume is low within the SUV 25-80 band; the boxy shape helps usability but raw capacity trails midsize rivals.
Max cargo volume with seats folded sits below the middle of the SUV 55-100 band.
Removable doors/roof and washable rubberized floors are novel utility, but door bins, console space and underfloor storage are cramped and dated compared to modern SUVs.
Flat, upright seats were consistently called out as a weak point; KBB owner survey specifically flagged comfort as the Wrangler's weakest attribute.
Solid front axle and off-road-tuned suspension produce an unsettled, snappy ride on pavement, widely criticized by reviewers.
Removable soft/hard top, boxy aerodynamics and knobby off-road tires produce heavy wind, road, and tire noise at highway speed, among the loudest cabins in the segment.
Heated front seats and heated steering wheel were optional only on upper Sahara trim via a cold-weather package; no rear climate controls or ventilated seats offered on any 2017 trim.
5Cost of OwnershipThe Wrangler's best-graded category.2.38C+
Entry 2-door Sport 4x4 is the cheapest configuration for MY2017; destination was $995 for most of the model year, rising to $1,095 later in the run.
The 4-door Unlimited body style accounted for the large majority of Wrangler sales by 2017, with Sport/Sport S and Sahara the volume trims; Unlimited Sport 4x4 is the representative configuration.
Solid-axle body-on-frame construction with straightforward mechanicals keeps individual repairs affordable, but the JK is a known-issue platform (TIPM electrical faults, oil cooler/filter housing leaks) that pushes 5-year totals to the higher end of the SUV band.
The Wrangler is a perennial class leader in resale value, consistently outperforming the midsize SUV average depreciation by a wide margin — a multi-year KBB Best Resale Value and 5-Year Cost to Own award winner through this generation.
Standard FCA bumper-to-bumper coverage for the era, matching the segment norm.
Standard FCA powertrain coverage for the era, matching the segment norm.
2017 predates the Jeep Wave loyalty program (launched circa 2019), so the only complimentary coverage was standard 5-year/60,000-mile roadside assistance bundled into the powertrain warranty — no complimentary scheduled maintenance, oil changes, or connected-service trials were included.
$32,870 volume-trim price minus its estimated resale value after 5 years (70% retained, or about $23,009) leaves about $9,861 in depreciation. Add the projected $7,300 in 5-year maintenance and repairs, and owning this vehicle for 5 years costs about $17,161 in total.
6Reliability & QualityOne of the Wrangler's strongest categories.1.82C-
JD Power's own quality/reliability rating for the 2017 Wrangler sits below average (2.5/5), but by 2017 the JK generation's Pentastar V6 era (2013-2017) is widely regarded by owners and independent trackers as the most sorted stretch of the JK's 11-year run, after the early cylinder-head and driveline issues of 2007-2012 were resolved. Mixed signal: below-average scored rating, but a genuinely improved track record within the generation.
Jeep has a persistent multi-year record of finishing in the bottom tier of J.D. Power's Vehicle Dependability Study and Consumer Reports brand rankings through the 2010s and into the following decade, a period that spans the 2017 model year.
The 2017 Wrangler carries several NHTSA recalls tied to its production window — a fuel tank control valve that could crack in a rollover (Nov 2016 build window), a brake-switch defect letting the vehicle be shifted out of Park without the brake pedal depressed (Aug-Sep 2017 builds), and a powertrain control module voltage-regulator chip that could cause stalling/no-start (2017-2018MY, campaign opened Oct 2018). None involve fire or a systemic powertrain failure across the whole model year, but the count and mix (safety, brake, powertrain electronics) is more than a clean sheet.
The 2017 Wrangler's 3.6L Pentastar V6 (standard, paired with a 5-speed automatic or 6-speed manual) is a proven, high-mileage-capable design by this point in its run — the early-2010s cylinder-head issues that affected the first Pentastar years were resolved well before 2017, and owner/mechanic consensus puts realistic longevity at 200,000-250,000+ miles with routine maintenance (oil cooler and water pump are the known wear items, not structural engine failures).
Reviewers consistently describe the JK-generation cabin as function-first: mostly hard, wipe-clean plastics with minimal soft-touch surfacing, a design choice that trades cabin richness for the doors-off/top-off/washable-interior utility the Wrangler is built around. It reads as basic even against other off-road-oriented SUVs at a similar price point, not just against mainstream crossovers.
Assembly of the fixed structure is generally solid, but the Wrangler's removable doors, fold-down windshield and lift-off hardtop are inherent sources of wind noise, water intrusion and rattles that a unibody SUV doesn't have to contend with — reviewers note a notably raw, loud cabin and scattered rattle/leak complaints tied specifically to those modular panels rather than to sloppy assembly of fixed body panels.
Jeep is sold through FCA's large, long-established US dealer network (shared with Dodge/Chrysler/Ram at most stores), giving it broad geographic coverage comparable to other domestic mainstream brands; service satisfaction for the brand is unremarkable rather than a standout in either direction.
The JK Wrangler has one of the largest aftermarket support ecosystems of any vehicle sold in the US — dedicated parts houses (Quadratec, Crown Automotive, Rough Country, Bestop, Teraflex, Omix-ADA and others) stock everything from wear items to full drivetrain components, keeping both OEM and aftermarket parts cheap and abundant relative to most SUVs, on top of Jeep's own dealer parts network.
7Technology & InfotainmentOne of the Wrangler's weakest categories.0.00F
Base Wrangler radios have no touchscreen at all; the largest available screen for 2017 is the optional 6.5 in Uconnect 430/430N unit, well below the SUV segment's 7-15.5 in band.
The dated Uconnect 430 interface (last refreshed years earlier for the JK) is functional but visually and technically behind the newer Uconnect 4/4C systems arriving elsewhere in the lineup by 2017.
The 2017 JK Wrangler's Uconnect 430 does not support Apple CarPlay or Android Auto in any form, wired or wireless, on any trim.
Basic voice-command calling/audio control and an optional GPS nav (Uconnect 430N/RBZ) are available, but the system is dated and nav is a costly add-on rather than a full-featured experience.
A 9-speaker Alpine premium audio system was optional on upper trims, but the base speaker setup is modest and open-top/soft-top acoustics undercut sound quality regardless of head unit.
The 2017 Wrangler uses analog gauges with only a small monochrome trip-computer display in the cluster; no configurable digital cluster is offered on any trim.
The JK-generation Uconnect system predates FCA's OTA update rollout; updates require a dealer visit or USB-loaded firmware, with no over-the-air capability.
Uconnect Access with remote functions was not offered on the 2017 Wrangler; owners have no factory remote-start/lock/locate app for this model.
A single USB port and 12V outlet are standard, with no wireless charging and no rear-row USB on any 2017 trim.
Remote keyless entry is standard, but proximity/push-button start and phone-as-key are not offered on the 2017 Wrangler at all.
A basic rear backup camera is available only as part of an option package (not standard even on Sahara), with no parking sensors or 360-degree camera offered on any trim.
No head-up display is offered on any 2017 Wrangler trim.
8Use-Case FitGrades near the bottom of the scale.0.25F
Narrow rear door openings, a high step-in, and a removable-door/soft-top design (which loses child-lock convenience) make everyday car-seat loading awkward; IIHS also rated LATCH anchor accessibility Marginal.
No forward-collision warning or automatic braking is offered on any 2017 trim, headlights rated Poor by IIHS, side crash rated Marginal, and the Wrangler is one of the few vehicles still sold without standard side airbags.
Loud cabin, choppy highway ride, flat seats, and minimal rear-seat amenities make multi-hour family trips notably uncomfortable compared to typical SUVs.
Consumer Reports describes handling as "very clumsy" with numb, slow steering, and a snappy ride — all fatiguing in daily commuting compared to typical SUVs.
The standard 3.6L V6 returns roughly 17/21 mpg city/highway, well below typical SUV commuting economy, driving higher per-mile fuel costs.
The compact footprint (especially the 2-door) helps in tight spaces, but a wide turning circle on the Unlimited, a rear-mounted spare blocking visibility, and no standard backup camera work against it.
Modest towing (2,000 lbs 2-door / 3,500 lbs 4-door) and payload (roughly 1,000-1,200 lbs) trail dedicated work vehicles, and there is no cargo bed.
Solid front and rear axles, skid plates, and a simple body-on-frame design give it a rugged, fleet/off-road-proven reputation, offset by mixed owner-reported reliability and several NHTSA recalls for this model year.
No bed or onboard power outlets for tools, and washable rubber floors help but there are few factory tie-downs or jobsite-oriented provisions; upfit ecosystem is overwhelmingly off-road/recreation focused rather than work focused.
Loud wind/road noise, a choppy ride, and no adaptive cruise or lane-keeping assistance make sustained highway stints tiring; fuel range is also modest given ~21 mpg highway and a roughly 18.6-gallon tank.
Best-in-class off-road hardware — solid axles, up to 10 in ground clearance, locking differentials and a 42.2-degree approach angle on Rubicon, plus a fully removable roof and doors — makes it a genuine adventure benchmark.
Folding rear seats and roof-rack availability accommodate bulky outdoor gear reasonably well, though raw cargo volume trails many midsize SUVs and the removable top limits secure lockable storage.
9Driving ExperienceGrades near the bottom of the scale.0.53F
Solid front axle, high center of gravity, and body-on-frame construction produce clumsy, top-heavy cornering behavior that Consumer Reports singled out as a weakness.
The recirculating-ball steering setup carried over from the JK generation is numb and slow to respond, criticized consistently by reviewers.
Braking is adequate for the vehicle's weight and use case but unremarkable, with a soft pedal typical of the segment and no standout stopping performance reported.
The 3.6L Pentastar V6 paired with the optional 5-speed automatic (or standard 6-speed manual) is a genuine strength of the JK generation — smooth and reasonably responsive, a notable improvement over the prior 3.8L V6.
Engine noise under load is acceptable, but wind, tire, and drivetrain noise combine at highway speed to make the cabin one of the louder in the segment, especially with the soft top fitted.
The 4-door Unlimited's turning circle is toward the wide end of the SUV 34-42 ft band (worse for maneuverability), a tradeoff of its longer wheelbase versus the tighter 2-door.
The upright seating position and tall stance give good outward visibility, but a tight, offset footwell (especially with the manual clutch) and a high step-in for shorter drivers are recurring complaints.
Despite poor on-road manners, the open-air experience, removable doors/roof, and unmatched off-road character make the Wrangler a genuine enthusiast favorite — owners and reviewers alike consistently describe it as fun despite its compromises.
10Value & Market PositionOne of the Wrangler's strongest categories.1.98C-
Base 2017 Sport trim was spartan by mainstream-SUV standards (vinyl floors, manual windows/locks available on the 2-door), but every trim included genuine off-road hardware — Command-Trac 4x4, tow hooks, skid plates, removable doors/top — that rivals don't offer at any price, which offsets the light on-road content.
Judged purely on content-per-dollar the Wrangler is unremarkable — interior materials and refinement lag mainstream crossovers at the same price — but factoring in genuine off-road capability and an aftermarket/customization ecosystem no rival matches, buyers get real capability-per-dollar even if not comfort-per-dollar.
Wide lineup for MY2017: Sport, Sport S, Sahara and Rubicon, each in 2-door and 4-door Unlimited body styles, manual or automatic transmission, plus special editions (75th Anniversary, Big Bear, Smoky Mountain, Chief), giving genuine spread from budget to loaded.
Wrangler sales were strong and climbing toward the record set by the following generation, with the nameplate effectively unrivaled in its off-road SUV niche since the Toyota FJ Cruiser's 2014 discontinuation — a near-default choice for dedicated off-road buyers.
The Wrangler carries the strongest brand halo in the Jeep lineup and one of the strongest in the industry — direct descendant of the WWII Jeep, with a large, loyal owner community and enthusiast following.
High demand and the off-road niche's lack of direct rivals meant Wrangler historically carried thin incentives and sold close to sticker — good for resale, poor for buyers hunting a deal.
2017 is the final model year of the JK generation that launched for 2007 (facelifted 2011) — the oldest possible point in its life cycle, with the all-new JL generation already announced and arriving for MY2018.
Reviewers consistently praised off-road capability and open-air versatility while dinging on-road refinement, wind noise and ride quality, so the Wrangler wins value/resale/loyalty-type awards rather than mainstream comparison tests or 10Best-style recognition.