The verdict
A mixed-report compact luxury sedan, strong on driving and held back by ownership.
Overall 2.31 (C+) across 10 graded subjects. Its strongest is driving experience at 3.57 (A-), its weakest cost of ownership at 0.00 (F). 6 of 10 subjects grade at C− or better.
Jump to scoresStrengths
- Driving Experience
- Value & Market Position
- Safety
What holds it back
- Cost of Ownership
- Efficiency & Range
- Use-Case Fit
Top alternatives
Cars shoppers cross-shop with the Alfa Romeo Giulia
3.07B
BMW 3 SeriesCompact Luxury SedanThe 3 Series is the segment default with a broader powertrain lineup (330i, M340i, plug-in hybrid abroad), a much larger 14.9-inch curved display, a bigger ~17 cu ft trunk, and vastly better resale — but the Giulia is the more emotional, better-steering car and looks more distinctive at the curb.
Compare
2.86B-
Audi A4Compact Luxury SedanThe A4 quattro matches the Giulia's 27 MPG combined but adds tri-zone climate, roomier back seat comfort features, and Audi's more solid fit-and-finish reputation.
Compare
2.79B-
Mercedes-Benz C-ClassCompact Luxury SedanThe C-Class walks over the Giulia inside with an 11.9-inch portrait screen, MBUX voice control, softer ride, and quieter cabin — it feels a full generation newer.
CompareHow it's evolved
10 scored model years · 2017–2026
Subject scores by year
Hover or tap a score to see what moved it versus the year before. A corner mark flags a big swing.
| Year | Performance | Efficiency | Safety | Space | Cost | Reliability | Tech | Use-case | Driving | Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 59 | 32 | 66 | 57 | 25 | 49 | 58 | 44 | 78 | 66 |
| 2025 | 57 | 28 | 60 | 63 | 30 | 66 | 56 | 50 | 81 | 67 |
| 2024 | 58 | 35 | 62 | 62 | 27 | 60 | 56 | 52 | 83 | 72 |
| 2023 | 57 | 37 | 65 | 61 | 13 | 63 | 52 | 51 | 82 | 71 |
| 2022 | 58 | 38 | 67 | 62 | 30 | 60 | 56 | 53 | 81 | 71 |
| 2021 | 57 | 32 | 61 | 61 | 31 | 57 | 52 | 50 | 81 | 76 |
| 2020 | 56 | 34 | 57 | 62 | 48 | 57 | 53 | 48 | 84 | 74 |
| 2019 | 57 | 32 | 61 | 62 | 52 | 57 | 43 | 51 | 84 | 78 |
| 2018 | 56 | 38 | 57 | 62 | 43 | 48 | 40 | 51 | 83 | 79 |
| 2017 | 58 | 37 | 57 | 66 | 51 | 47 | 34 | 53 | 81 | 84 |
Compare two years
Best fit & conditions
Higher scores mean a better fit for that use case. Learn more about use-case fit →
Subject profile
Detailed scoring by subject
1Performance & PowertrainMid-pack among this car's ten categories.1.87C-
The volume 2.0-liter turbo-four produces 280 hp; the separate Quadrifoglio performance flagship reaches 505 hp.
The volume 2.0-liter turbo-four delivers a strong 306 lb-ft at a low 2,000 rpm.
The representative rear-drive 2.0T reaches 60 mph in 5.7 seconds in instrumented testing, while AWD cuts two tenths.
The turbo-four is unusually lively and responsive for a base luxury-sedan engine, but reviewers note a hollow, coarse character at low rpm and some roughness when worked. This keeps refinement well below the best luxury powertrains despite its strong output.
The ZF eight-speed provides engaging manual control and generally suits the engine, but slow kickdowns and inconsistent smoothness prevent a top-band score.
Q4 all-wheel drive is optional across the five mainstream 2.0T trims, giving buyers broad access rather than reserving it for an expensive top trim. It is a pavement-focused automatic system without terrain modes or low range, and the Quadrifoglio remains RWD-only.
The lineup offers two genuinely distinct choices: the broadly available 280-hp turbo-four and the 505-hp twin-turbo V6 Quadrifoglio. That covers mainstream and extreme-performance buyers, but there is no hybrid, plug-in, EV, or intermediate engine.
2Efficiency & RangeOne of the Giulia's weakest categories.0.44F
The volume rear-drive 2.0T earns 27 MPG combined on the 2023 EPA cycle.
The volume rear-drive 2.0T is EPA-rated at 24 MPG city.
The volume rear-drive 2.0T is EPA-rated at 33 MPG highway.
A full 15.3-gallon tank at the EPA combined rating yields about 413 miles. Published city/highway range endpoints are 367.2 and 504.9 miles.
EPA's standard 15,000-mile annual estimate is relatively costly because its calculation prices the car on premium gasoline.
Regular 87-octane gasoline is permitted, so premium is not a hard operating requirement; 91 octane is recommended for optimal performance. The recommendation slightly reduces the score versus a car fully optimized for regular fuel.
3SafetyOne of the Giulia's strongest categories.2.37C+
NHTSA did not publish an overall rating for the 2023 Giulia or another U.S. model year of this generation. The required numeric value is therefore a conservative estimate anchored by the generation's strong IIHS crashworthiness results, not a claimed government rating.
The Giulia earned Good results in every IIHS crashworthiness test published for 2023, but it had no current Top Safety Pick award and lacked newer passenger-side small-overlap, updated moderate-overlap, and updated side evaluations.
Sprint includes AEB, full-stop adaptive cruise, blind-spot monitoring, and lane-departure warning, but rear cross-path detection is packaged and lane-keep/highway assist are unavailable on Sprint. Thus four core functions are standard, but the volume trim lacks standard RCTA and active lane keeping.
Standard AEB earned IIHS Superior vehicle-to-vehicle performance, avoiding the 12-mph collision and nearly eliminating impact speed at 25 mph. IIHS did not publish pedestrian day/night results for this model, preventing a top-tier score.
Blind-spot monitoring is standard on all trims, but rear cross-path detection is package content on the volume Sprint and the base system is alert-only. Active blind-spot steering intervention requires Active Assist Plus, which is not offered on Sprint.
The volume Sprint has only standard lane-departure warning, not steering assistance. Lane Keep Assist and Highway Assist lane centering are available through Active Assist Plus on Ti and higher trims, making functional centering available but gated above the representative trim.
Full-speed ACC with full stop is unusually standard on every trim and contemporary testing describes it as responsive and easy to adjust. Integrated Highway Assist and Traffic Jam Assist are available above Sprint, so the volume trim does not receive the complete combined system.
No hands-free highway-driving system was offered. Available Highway Assist is a hands-on Level 2 aid rather than a mapped-road hands-free system.
Every 2023 trim has the same Good-rated curve-adaptive bi-xenon projectors with automatic high beams. IIHS found good low-beam visibility in every curve test and no excessive glare.
Forward visibility is generally workable, but the low sport-sedan seating position, rising beltline, and substantial rear roof pillars create rear-quarter blind zones. A backup camera and front/rear sensors are standard, though no surround-view camera is listed to fully compensate.
IIHS rates LATCH usability Marginal: both outboard positions have complete hardware, but the lower anchors are too deep and difficult to maneuver around. The center position offers only a tether, and compact rear quarters can constrain rear-facing seats.
4Space & ComfortMid-pack among this car's ten categories.2.13C
The volume 2023 Giulia Sprint is a five-passenger sedan.
Front headroom is comfortably above the sedan-band midpoint and is one of the Giulia's stronger passenger-space measurements.
The low, driver-focused front compartment provides competitive legroom for a compact luxury sedan.
Rear headroom is respectable despite the sedan's sloping roofline.
The rear seat is notably tighter than the front and trails roomier compact-luxury rivals.
The US-market specification is modest, though the standard 40/20/40 folding rear seat improves usefulness.
Basic door pockets, cupholders, an armrest bin and a tunnel net cover daily needs, but the cabin lacks generous or inventive storage.
Standard heated leather seats have strong power adjustment and lumbar support, but the tight rear bench and mixed long-haul feedback prevent a leading score.
The base sport suspension stays controlled and civilized but has a firm edge, especially over cracked pavement.
Acoustic glazing helps, yet road and low-rpm engine noise keep the cabin from luxury-class serenity.
Unusually rich standard equipment includes dual-zone climate, rear vents, heated front and rear seats, and wireless charging; a heated wheel is packaged on Sprint and standard above it.
5Cost of OwnershipThe Giulia's lowest-graded category.0.00F
The Sprint RWD was the entry 2023 U.S. Giulia; its $44,280 base price becomes $45,875 with the mandatory destination charge.
The midrange Ti AWD is the representative volume configuration, pairing the mainstream 280-hp four-cylinder with the commonly chosen Q4 system and additional luxury equipment.
Edmunds projects exceptionally high service and repair expense for the representative Ti AWD, far beyond the sedan normalization ceiling.
Giulia depreciation is steep even by compact-luxury-sedan standards, substantially increasing the cost of buying new.
Coverage matches the standard term offered by most established luxury competitors.
Alfa provides no longer separate powertrain term, leaving coverage below rivals that extend powertrain protection to six or ten years.
One year/10,000 miles of scheduled service is useful but short, while four years of unlimited-mile roadside assistance adds a meaningful ownership perk.
$49,915 volume-trim price minus its estimated resale value after 5 years (37.5% retained, or about $18,718) leaves about $31,197 in depreciation. Add the projected $18,064 in 5-year maintenance and repairs, and owning this vehicle for 5 years costs about $49,261 in total.
6Reliability & QualityMid-pack among this car's ten categories.2.25C
The 2023 Giulia benefits from six years of production maturity and the substantial 2020 cabin/electronics update, but the major US survey sources do not establish it as a dependable class leader. Later cars appear materially better than early Giulias, yet the absence of sufficient Consumer Reports data and continued caution from major reviewers keep it near the middle of the band.
Alfa Romeo's long-term US dependability record remains below the luxury mainstream and the brand often lacks enough samples for CR or J.D. Power VDS ranking. Its exceptional 2023 initial-quality result is encouraging, but a 90-day study cannot by itself establish multi-year durability.
Three recalls is moderate rather than clean, and two broad campaigns affect visibility or restraint-related safety compliance. None establishes a repeated 2023-model powertrain, fire, or catastrophic mechanical defect, while the most serious fuel-pump investigation and recall activity centered on early-generation 2017-2020 cars.
The volume Ti's 280-hp 2.0-liter turbo four and ZF eight-speed had been in service since the Giulia's US launch, and later examples have no well-documented epidemic of internal engine or transmission failure. Electrical faults, weak-battery symptoms, coolant leaks, and occasional drivability complaints prevent a high score, but the conventional ZF automatic is a relative strength.
The Giulia Ti has an attractive, genuinely upscale cabin with abundant leather, soft-touch plastic, and metallic or wood trim. Material richness is competitive but not class-leading because some secondary controls and lower surfaces feel less substantial than in the Audi A4, BMW 3 Series, and Mercedes-Benz C-Class.
Alfa's best-in-class 2023 premium-brand initial-quality result supports above-average assembly quality, especially after the Giulia's 2020 material and infotainment revisions. A persistent rattle in Edmunds' test car and scattered owner reports keep the score below the tightest-built rivals.
The specialist US network is sparse enough that many owners face long travel or limited choice when a dealer relationship goes poorly. Coverage is markedly weaker than the national networks supporting Lexus, BMW, Mercedes-Benz, or Cadillac, making warranty work and Alfa-specific diagnosis less convenient.
Seven model years of shared Giulia/Stelvio mechanical hardware provide some independent-shop and aftermarket support, but Alfa-specific parts remain costlier and less readily stocked than those for higher-volume rivals. Dealer dependence, delivery delays, and European-luxury labor costs make out-of-warranty ownership a notable risk.
7Technology & InfotainmentGrades below the middle of the scale.1.51D
The sole center display is small by 2023 luxury-sedan standards.
Touch and rotary-controller operation make the system reasonably intuitive, but small icons and slow navigation responses date the experience.
Both projection systems are standard but require a cable, falling short of the requested wireless capability.
Native 3-D navigation and voice recognition are standard, but the navigation can lag at crucial turns and most users will prefer phone maps.
The base eight-speaker setup is adequate and a substantial 900-watt, 14-speaker Harman Kardon system is accessible from Ti upward.
The 2023 US car retains analog primary gauges around a configurable 7-inch TFT; the 12.3-inch digital facelift cluster arrived for North American model year 2024.
The Connect system supports over-the-air infotainment updates, but there is no evidence of Tesla-style whole-vehicle feature deployment.
Alfa Connect services provide core connected functions, while key remote-start access is also handled conventionally by the standard fob; no phone-as-key is offered.
Four USB outlets and standard wireless charging are generous, though the documentation does not promise abundant fast USB-C or an AC outlet.
Passive entry, push-button start and remote start are standard across the lineup, but phone-as-key is absent.
Front and rear parking sensors are standard with a dynamic-grid rear camera, but no factory surround-view camera or automated parking system is listed.
A head-up display was not offered on the 2023 US Giulia.
8Use-Case FitOne of the Giulia's weakest categories.1.44D
Two complete LATCH positions and folding seats help, but tight rear space, small door openings and a modest trunk make routine child-seat loading awkward.
Crashworthiness and standard collision avoidance are strong, though lane centering and related Level 2 aids require a package and LATCH usability is only Marginal.
Heated rear seats, rear vents and a folding seatback are welcome, but 35.1 inches of rear legroom, firm ride and limited luggage capacity constrain four-person touring.
Compact dimensions, good front-seat adjustment and standard adaptive cruise make commuting easy, offset by a firm ride, fussy shifter and imperfect stop-start/transmission polish.
Twenty-seven mpg combined is strong for a 280-hp luxury sport sedan, but premium gasoline and luxury-car consumables keep costs merely average overall.
A compact footprint, 35.5-foot turning diameter, standard front/rear sensors and a rear camera make it easy to place, despite no surround view.
This low-slung luxury sedan is not rated or equipped in the US as a meaningful tow, payload or commercial-work vehicle.
Leather trim, low-profile run-flat tires and a luxury-oriented cabin are ill suited to repeated jobsite abuse, with no fleet-work reputation to compensate.
There are no tie-down systems, onboard AC power, rack packages, washable surfaces or commercial upfit provisions.
Efficient highway economy, supportive power seats, acoustic front glass and available highway assist make it a capable tourer, but firm ride, road noise and tight rear quarters limit endurance.
Optional Q4 AWD handles weather and gravel, but low clearance, no US tow rating and sedan packaging make it a weak adventure platform.
The standard 40/20/40 rear seat and power trunk release add flexibility, but bulky gear remains constrained by a small sedan opening and 13.4-cu-ft trunk.
9Driving ExperienceThe Giulia's best-graded category.3.57A-
The Giulia remains the compact-luxury class benchmark for balance, body control and agility even in four-cylinder form.
Exceptionally quick, precise and communicative steering is a defining Giulia strength, though its immediacy may feel nervous to relaxed drivers.
Standard four-piston Brembo front brakes provide substantial hardware and a firm, consistent everyday pedal, though brake-by-wire feel and all-season tires temper ultimate confidence.
The 280-hp turbo four and ZF eight-speed deliver eager response and strong everyday performance, but occasional low-speed transmission and stop-start roughness costs polish.
The engine becomes engaging when worked but can sound hollow and coarse at low rpm, with more vibration and noise than the best luxury rivals.
The tight turning diameter enhances urban maneuverability for a rear-drive sport sedan.
A low, sporty position, broad power-seat adjustment and excellent wheel/pedal relationship suit enthusiastic driving, but visibility and a few controls draw complaints.
Few sedans combine this much steering immediacy, chassis balance, rear-drive character and accessible performance; it actively rewards taking the long route.
10Value & Market PositionOne of the Giulia's strongest categories.2.78B-
Even the Sprint includes leather, heated front and rear seats, adaptive cruise, blind-spot monitoring, lane-departure warning, Brembo front brakes, wireless charging, and an 8.8-inch touchscreen. Advanced lane-centering functions remain optional above Sprint, preventing a top-band score.
The standard 280-hp engine, excellent chassis, rich base equipment and available RWD/AWD deliver strong performance value around $46,000-$50,000. Aging infotainment, costly options and very high ownership costs keep it short of standout overall value.
Six trims span luxury, sport and high-performance priorities, with RWD or AWD on every four-cylinder trim and a distinct 505-hp Quadrifoglio halo model. The absence of a hybrid or intermediate six-cylinder is the principal gap.
The Giulia was a low-volume U.S. niche model and its sales fell sharply during 2023, signaling weak acceptance against the German compact-luxury leaders.
Alfa Romeo's Italian design, motorsport heritage and enthusiast appeal give the Giulia unusual emotional cachet. A thin dealer footprint and persistent reliability concerns weaken mainstream luxury confidence and resale.
Weak demand made meaningful dealer discounts readily obtainable, delivering strong immediate buyer benefit even though the discounting reflected market weakness.
The 2023 U.S. Giulia was in the seventh model year of the generation that began in 2017, with new Lusso and Estrema packaging but no major redesign. The facelift announced in late 2022 did not reach North America until model year 2024, leaving 2023 buyers exposed to immediate obsolescence.
Reviewers consistently celebrate the steering, chassis and styling, especially the Quadrifoglio, but rank the regular Giulia below the class leaders because of cabin practicality, dated technology and reliability concerns. Its enthusiast acclaim is stronger than its formal 2023 award record.
