The verdict
A struggling subcompact hatchback, strong on driving and held back by performance.
Overall 1.33 (D) across 10 graded subjects. Its strongest is driving experience at 3.29 (B+), its weakest performance & powertrain at 0.00 (F). 6 of 10 subjects grade at C− or better.
Jump to scoresStrengths
- Driving Experience
- Cost of Ownership
- Technology & Infotainment
What holds it back
- Performance & Powertrain
- Space & Comfort
- Use-Case Fit
Top alternatives
Cars shoppers cross-shop with the Fiat 500e
1.78C-
Mini Cooper HardtopSubcompact HatchbackBetter at: Driving funThe same small-car charm with more power, better dynamics, a stronger dealer network and far better resale — the cross-shop nearly every 500e shopper actually makes.
Compare
2.09C
Nissan LeafCompact HatchbackBetter at: RangeIf you want an affordable EV rather than this specific piece of design, the Leaf offers substantially more range and four usable doors for the money.
Compare
1.80C-
Kia SoulSubcompact HatchbackBetter at: Space for moneyCheaper, far roomier inside for the same tiny parking footprint, with a long warranty and dealers everywhere.
CompareHow it's evolved
6 scored model years · 2017–2026
Subject scores by year
Hover or tap a score to see what moved it versus the year before. A corner mark flags a big swing.
| Year | Performance | Efficiency | Safety | Space | Cost | Reliability | Tech | Use-case | Driving | Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 27 | 57 | 52 | 32 | 54 | 44 | 65 | 39 | 73 | 52 |
| 2025 | 26 | 57 | 43 | 28 | 57 | 52 | 62 | 37 | 77 | 63 |
| 2024 | 29 | 57 | 44 | 31 | 69 | 57 | 65 | 41 | 78 | 62 |
| 2019 | 27 | 59 | 21 | 28 | 55 | 53 | 29 | 35 | 78 | 43 |
| 2018 | 27 | 59 | 20 | 29 | 55 | 58 | 33 | 35 | 79 | 53 |
| 2017 | 27 | 59 | 24 | 28 | 59 | 55 | 33 | 36 | 81 | 57 |
Compare two years
Best fit & conditions
Higher scores mean a better fit for that use case. Learn more about use-case fit →
Subject profile
Detailed scoring by subject
1Performance & PowertrainThe 500e's lowest-graded category.0.00F
The 2024 U.S.-market 500e uses one 87-kW front motor across the range, rated at 117 hp. This is below the 130-hp floor of the hatchback normalization band.
Instant electric-motor torque makes the car feel lively at city speeds, although the raw output is modest by current EV standards.
The instrumented 7.8-second result is better than Fiat's conservative claim but still merely adequate among modern EV hatchbacks.
Motor delivery is smooth, quiet, and responsive at urban speeds, with effective selectable one-pedal operation. Power fades at highway speed and Range mode slightly softens initial response, keeping it just below the top band.
The single-speed direct drive has no shifts to hunt or interrupt acceleration and operates transparently. Normal mode coasts like a conventional car, while Range mode provides smooth one-pedal control.
Every 2024 U.S. 500e is front-wheel drive; no AWD or 4WD configuration was offered.
The 2024 U.S. lineup offered one battery, one 117-hp motor, front-wheel drive, and direct drive across its appearance-led editions. There was no alternate motor output, dual-motor model, hybrid, or combustion option.
2Efficiency & RangeMid-pack among this car's ten categories.1.84C-
The representative U.S. configuration uses its standard all-season tires; the no-cost summer-tire configuration receives the higher EPA rating shown for context.
The small, light EV is particularly efficient in city use, where regenerative braking and low-speed operation favor it.
Highway efficiency remains respectable but trails its city result, as expected for a short-range urban EV.
The standard all-season configuration's 141-mile EPA range is exceptionally short among current EVs and falls below the EV-hatchback band's 230-mile floor.
An 85-kW peak is low by modern EV standards, though the small battery limits how much energy must be added.
FIAT quotes about 35 minutes to reach 80% but does not consistently state the starting charge in U.S. material; an instrumented 13–80% result of 34 minutes closely supports 35 minutes as the representative 10–80% figure.
The EPA estimate reflects low energy consumption and gives the 500e a substantial operating-cost advantage over combustion hatchbacks.
Its small battery recharges in about six hours on Level 2 and is inexpensive to keep charged, but public charging is limited to 85-kW CCS and the 2024 car lacks native NACS access. Home charging is straightforward, while the short range makes dependable access more important.
3SafetyGrades near the bottom of the scale.0.94F
NHTSA lists the exact 2024 Fiat 500e three-door hatchback but reports every NCAP category, including overall, as Not Rated. A neutral 4-star estimate preserves the required numeric field without presenting it as a test result.
IIHS has not published a crashworthiness evaluation or award for the U.S.-market third-generation 500e. With no institute results to substantiate structural performance, it falls just inside the rubric's untested band rather than receiving credit for an assumed result.
The sole 2024 (RED) volume trim supplies the core forward-collision/AEB and lane-warning functions, but not the comprehensive five-feature suite: adaptive cruise, blind-spot monitoring and rear cross-traffic alert were not standard on the 2024 launch car.
Full-speed forward-collision warning with automatic braking and pedestrian/cyclist detection is useful standard hardware, but neither IIHS nor NHTSA has published performance testing for the 2024 500e, especially nighttime pedestrian results.
Blind-spot monitoring, rear cross-traffic alert/braking and safe-exit assistance were not offered on the sole 2024 U.S. launch trim. The backup camera and parking sensors do not replace side-traffic coverage.
Active Lane Management adds steering correction rather than warning alone, but the 2024 car has no documented hands-on lane-centering/highway-assist mode and no comparative instrumented evaluation. It is functional basic lane keeping, not class-leading centering.
The 2024 U.S. 500e has conventional cruise control, not adaptive cruise, and offers no integrated highway-assist system. Active Driving Assist became an available option in later U.S. configurations and must not be carried backward to this launch model year.
No hands-free highway-driving system was available on the 2024 500e. Its lane-management system requires continuous driver supervision and is not a mapped-road hands-free product.
Full-LED projector headlights and automatic high beams are favorable standard equipment, but IIHS has not tested their illumination or glare. The hardware merits a mid-band score without assuming a Good rating.
The upright windshield and compact dimensions make the car easy to place, while the thick rear pillars and small rear-quarter glass create meaningful over-shoulder blind zones. A standard backup camera and rear parking sensors help when reversing, but there is no surround-view camera.
Two-door access, a very short rear bench and tight rear legroom make installing and using rear-facing seats cumbersome, and three-across is unrealistic. Two outboard LATCH positions are present, but the body layout imposes a major everyday penalty.
4Space & ComfortOne of the 500e's weakest categories.0.00F
The two-door 500e has two front seats and a two-place rear bench.
The tall city-car roof provides unusually generous clearance up front.
Front legroom is adequate and substantially more accommodating than the tiny rear compartment.
Rear headroom sits near the bottom of the hatchback normalization range.
This is below the hatchback scoring floor and reviewers describe the rear seat as child-sized.
The luggage compartment falls below even the framework's 8-cu-ft hatchback floor.
A useful center hideaway and folding cupholder cannot offset narrow pockets, one usable front cupholder and no frunk.
Front padding is acceptable but the flat, firm seats lack lateral support, while the rear bench is unsuitable for adults beyond short trips.
It is composed on smooth urban roads but short-wheelbase firmness and bounce emerge sharply on broken pavement.
The silent motor helps in town, but road and wind noise make highway refinement merely average for an EV.
Automatic climate control and remote preconditioning are standard, but the volume (RED) trim lacks heated seats and a heated steering wheel; heated seats came on the pricier Beauty and Music editions.
5Cost of OwnershipOne of the 500e's strongest categories.2.64C+
The INSPI(RED) launch trim was both the entry and volume configuration for the 2024 U.S. model.
INSPI(RED) is the representative volume trim; Edmunds recommends it as the best-value 2024 configuration and Consumer Reports purchased one at the same delivered price.
Edmunds' model-year- and trim-specific estimate assumes 15,000 miles annually; the requested combined figure is the sum of its maintenance and repair totals.
This is an industry residual projection rather than an observed five-year result for the new generation.
Fiat's coverage exceeds the common three-year term, though it is not class-leading.
The EV drivetrain and battery receive the standard long-duration EV coverage.
There is no included scheduled-maintenance program, but the choice of Level 2 charging hardware or $600 public-charging credit is a meaningful ownership perk, supplemented by three years of app connectivity.
$34,095 volume-trim price minus its estimated resale value after 5 years (52% retained, or about $17,729) leaves about $16,366 in depreciation. Add the projected $5,235 in 5-year maintenance and repairs, and owning this vehicle for 5 years costs about $21,601 in total.
6Reliability & QualityMid-pack among this car's ten categories.1.87C-
The 2024 model is the first U.S. year of this generation, and neither Consumer Reports nor J.D. Power had enough model-specific owner data for a meaningful prediction. Several years of European use without a widely reported catastrophic pattern help, but launch-year software and body-system bulletins keep the outlook near average rather than above it.
Fiat lacks a strong, consistently measured U.S. dependability record and was omitted from the 2024 CR brand ranking for insufficient data. Its tiny recent U.S. presence also makes the available evidence less robust than for established hatchback brands.
The U.S. launch-year record has one safety recall, and it is consequential because an improperly connected buckle sensor could prevent the front airbag from deploying as intended. The broader bulletin pattern includes several correctable launch-quality items, but no documented systemic traction-battery or drive-motor recall.
The 42-kWh battery and GKN electric drive were new to U.S. buyers in 2024 but had already accumulated roughly four years of European production experience. No major systemic battery or motor failure campaign surfaced in the official U.S. record, though this remains too young and too low-volume domestically for a proven high-mileage rating.
The design is cheerful and distinctive, but extensive hard plastic on the dashboard, doors, and console is disappointing for this premium-priced subcompact. Reviewers consistently describe the materials as acceptable at best rather than genuinely upscale.
Test vehicles showed tight assembly with no rattles or squeaks, which is notably better than the material-quality impression. Window and water-intrusion bulletins prevent a stronger score because they reveal some early production inconsistency.
Fiat has franchised U.S. coverage and Stellantis/Mopar roadside support, but its footprint is sparse compared with mainstream hatchback brands and high-voltage work requires a certified 500e facility and technician. That makes metropolitan ownership workable while rural support can be inconvenient.
Routine EV maintenance is simple, but this imported, extremely low-volume U.S. model has little domestic aftermarket depth and specialized high-voltage or body parts are largely dealer-channel items. The warranty cushions early failures, yet post-warranty repair access and cost are less favorable than for high-volume rivals.
7Technology & InfotainmentOne of the 500e's strongest categories.2.37C+
The same large-for-the-cabin screen is standard on every 2024 U.S. edition.
Uconnect 5 has straightforward menus and useful physical climate controls, though Edmunds observed lag and low-looking resolution.
Both wireless smartphone-projection systems are standard on the volume trim.
Native GPS navigation and Uconnect voice recognition are standard and functional, though the maps are less detailed than class leaders.
The volume (RED) trim's six-speaker stereo is serviceable; a notably better seven-speaker JBL system was confined to Inspired by Music.
A crisp 7-inch TFT digital cluster is standard, but its size and customization are modest rather than class-leading.
Uconnect supports Wi-Fi software updates and Fiat issued a 2024 FOTA radio update, but evidence supports infotainment rather than whole-vehicle feature updates.
Fiat Connect provides charging/status and remote climate functions, a useful but not digital-key-level suite.
Standard wireless charging plus front USB-A and USB-C is strong for such a tiny cabin, though there are no rear or AC outlets.
Passive entry and keyless ignition are standard, but there is no phone-as-key or hands-free hatch.
The volume trim includes a rear camera and rear parking sensors, but lacks a surround-view camera and automated parking.
No head-up display was offered on any 2024 U.S. 500e edition.
8Use-Case FitOne of the 500e's weakest categories.0.72F
Two doors, 29.5 inches of rear legroom and a 7.5-cu-ft hatch make installing seats and carrying a stroller regularly frustrating.
Automatic emergency braking, lane-departure warning and blind-spot monitoring are standard, but the volume trim lacks adaptive cruise/lane centering and no NHTSA or IIHS crash rating was available.
Four nominal seats cannot overcome child-sized rear space, tiny luggage capacity, sparse rear amenities and short EV range.
Compact dimensions, excellent visibility, smooth EV response and effective one-pedal Range mode make urban traffic exceptionally easy.
It is exceptionally energy-efficient and has modest tire/power demands, making home-charged commuting very inexpensive.
A 143-inch body, superb outward visibility and a 31.5-ft turning circle make this one of the easiest new cars to park.
With no published tow rating and only 7.5 cu ft behind the rear seat, it is useful for small errands rather than meaningful work.
The city-car chassis and fashion-oriented cabin were not designed for jobsite abuse, and the U.S. launch-year fleet record is unproven.
It offers no onboard AC power, cargo tie-down system, factory rack/upfit ecosystem or washable work interior.
A 141-149-mile EPA range, 120-mile 75-mph test result, highway noise and firm broken-road ride make frequent long stops unavoidable.
Front-wheel drive, 4.5 inches of clearance, no tow rating and a ride that deteriorates on rough surfaces keep it pavement-bound.
The 50/50 rear backrest adds some flexibility, but it does not fold flat and the tiny cargo bay severely limits bulky gear.
9Driving ExperienceThe 500e's best-graded category.3.29B+
The low battery and tiny footprint produce nimble, stable city handling, but understeer, body roll and bouncy responses stop it short of hot-hatch territory.
Quick, light steering is ideal for parking but transmits little road feedback.
Strong panic-stop performance and a usable choice between conventional coasting and one-pedal regeneration inspire confidence.
Immediate, smooth EV torque feels lively around town and the three modes are cleanly calibrated, despite modest highway acceleration.
The electric motor is nearly silent and vibration-free in normal use, though some high-speed motor whine is audible.
This is substantially tighter than the framework's 34-ft top-scoring hatchback threshold.
Tall glass, short overhangs, good driver-seat adjustment and physical climate switches work well, though firm flat seating and two-door access constrain comfort.
Instant low-speed response, characterful styling and darty dimensions make city drives charming, but it does not reward hard driving like a sporty Mini.
10Value & Market PositionMid-pack among this car's ten categories.2.19C
The volume INSPI(RED) includes a 10.25-inch touchscreen, wireless phone integration, navigation and substantial driver assistance, plus charging hardware or credits. Omissions such as heated seats and the very small cabin keep it below the loaded-at-base tier.
At $34,095 it is relatively affordable for a new EV, but its 149-mile maximum range, tiny rear seat and cargo hold give similarly priced electric rivals much more capability.
Three fixed, similarly priced appearance-and-feature editions provide some choice, but all share one motor, battery, body and front-wheel-drive layout with essentially no option-package flexibility.
The reintroduced generation was an exceptionally slow U.S. seller in its launch year, showing little market acceptance despite being new.
The 500's distinctive Italian style and heritage create real charm, but Fiat's tiny U.S. footprint and weak sales limit mainstream brand pull and likely weigh on resale.
Buyer benefit was extraordinary: lease-credit support and deep dealer/state-backed offers made payments extremely low, although the intensity also reflected weak demand.
The 2024 model is the U.S. debut of the all-new generation on a dedicated EV architecture, with a larger battery, much longer range and faster charging than the prior U.S. 500e.
Reviews found it charming, efficient and city-friendly but compromised by range, space and value; one green-car award adds recognition without making it a consistent comparison winner.
